Looking for IEM Recommendations for Subway Commute
Mar 9, 2017 at 7:56 PM Thread Starter Post #1 of 8

FutureBard

New Head-Fier
Joined
Mar 9, 2017
Posts
4
Likes
10
Hello! First time poster here. My set of decent IEMs recently died, and I'm looking to upgrade to something a bit better. I've been doing a bunch of reading, but haven't been able to settle on anything. The primary use case will be commuting (subway or walking), so excellent isolation and good durability are at a premium. I listen to a mix of mostly prog, melodic styles of metal, and jazz. My budget is about $150 CAD + Tax, but I'm willing to push it a little bit.
 
Important factors:
 
1) Durability. I take good care of my gear, but these are going to be going in and out of a carrying case, and used on rush hour subways and the like. They need to be reasonably robust.
2) Noise isolation. Again, rush hour subways. The best sound in the world isn't any good to me if I can't hear it over the train.
3) Sound quality. I tend to lean towards a flatter headphone, I think. Instrument isolation is very important; I play bass, and there's nothing worse than not being able to pick the bass out of the mix.

Based on everything I've read, these are the options that are on my radar:
 
Shure SE215 - Seem to consistently get top marks for durability and isolation, but sound quality is fairly hit or miss.
 
RHA MA750 - Good reviews for durability (though I'm rather concerned by the presense of a straight plug) and sound. How does isolation stack up?
 
Audio Tehcnia ATH-E40 - These looks really promising, but I've had trouble finding comparisons between them and other options. I've enjoyed other AT stuff in the past.
 
Etymotic HF5 - Top marks for isolation and sound quality (and I'm not worried about the tips; I've used triple flange earplugs with no issues). I'm a little concerned about durability on these ones.
 
MEE Audio M6 Pro - Some people seem to swear by them as being much better than the SE215s. Others criticize them for being less durable, isolating less, or having an excessive harsh character in the trebles.

Which of these would you suggest for my needs? Is there anything I haven't considered that I should? Thanks in advance for any help.
 
Mar 9, 2017 at 8:56 PM Post #2 of 8
  Hello! First time poster here. My set of decent IEMs recently died, and I'm looking to upgrade to something a bit better. I've been doing a bunch of reading, but haven't been able to settle on anything. The primary use case will be commuting (subway or walking), so excellent isolation and good durability are at a premium. I listen to a mix of mostly prog, melodic styles of metal, and jazz. My budget is about $150 CAD + Tax, but I'm willing to push it a little bit.
 
Important factors:
 
1) Durability. I take good care of my gear, but these are going to be going in and out of a carrying case, and used on rush hour subways and the like. They need to be reasonably robust.
2) Noise isolation. Again, rush hour subways. The best sound in the world isn't any good to me if I can't hear it over the train.
3) Sound quality. I tend to lean towards a flatter headphone, I think. Instrument isolation is very important; I play bass, and there's nothing worse than not being able to pick the bass out of the mix.

Based on everything I've read, these are the options that are on my radar:
 
Shure SE215 - Seem to consistently get top marks for durability and isolation, but sound quality is fairly hit or miss.
 
RHA MA750 - Good reviews for durability (though I'm rather concerned by the presense of a straight plug) and sound. How does isolation stack up?
 
Audio Tehcnia ATH-E40 - These looks really promising, but I've had trouble finding comparisons between them and other options. I've enjoyed other AT stuff in the past.
 
Etymotic HF5 - Top marks for isolation and sound quality (and I'm not worried about the tips; I've used triple flange earplugs with no issues). I'm a little concerned about durability on these ones.
 
MEE Audio M6 Pro - Some people seem to swear by them as being much better than the SE215s. Others criticize them for being less durable, isolating less, or having an excessive harsh character in the trebles.

Which of these would you suggest for my needs? Is there anything I haven't considered that I should? Thanks in advance for any help.

I would add the 1More Triple Driver to your list. It is fairly neutral and really sounds terrific. Is durable and isolates well. It is a very good value. You might read about it. I would also say that IMO, the MA750 has pretty good isolation and superb durability, plus a three-year warranty. My ranking of those you list plus my addition would be: 1More>RHA>hf5>MEE>Shure--I haven't heard the E40, sorry.
 
Mar 9, 2017 at 11:47 PM Post #4 of 8
  I would add the 1More Triple Driver to your list. It is fairly neutral and really sounds terrific. Is durable and isolates well. It is a very good value. You might read about it. I would also say that IMO, the MA750 has pretty good isolation and superb durability, plus a three-year warranty. My ranking of those you list plus my addition would be: 1More>RHA>hf5>MEE>Shure--I haven't heard the E40, sorry.

I saw that it had good reviews for sound, but didn't see much about isolation or durability. I'll definitely add it to the list.
 
  Are you interested in Nuforce Primo 8? It's a quad-drive IEM and sounds similar to Shure SE535. I have one for sale.

I don't think I'm looking to buy second-hand for this, but thanks for the offer.
 
Mar 16, 2017 at 6:13 PM Post #5 of 8
Bumping this thread for a follow-up question. I was looking at the m750s as the most likely candidate (at $140), but discovered that the 1More Dual Drivers are on sale for $60. Is anything discussed in this thread enough of an improvement over the dual drivers to justify being more than twice the price?
 
Mar 16, 2017 at 6:48 PM Post #6 of 8
  Bumping this thread for a follow-up question. I was looking at the m750s as the most likely candidate (at $140), but discovered that the 1More Dual Drivers are on sale for $60. Is anything discussed in this thread enough of an improvement over the dual drivers to justify being more than twice the price?

The MA750 are certainly  not twice the IEM that the 1More are, IMHO. I consider them different, but roughly equivalent overall.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top