Quote:
Originally Posted by FalconP /img/forum/go_quote.gif
I loved Amarok 1.x. Amarok 2 is a JOKE -- the blasted thing can't even play audio CDs (developers' excuse: no one in the team plays audio CDs anymore. If we are to implement the "play audio CD" function we'd just rip your CD and play the files. So, why don't you just rip the CD yourself, and then use Amarok to play the files?). Luckily I can use Kaffeine to play CDs, without having to rip them first.
|
ETA - I've just seen that Amarok 2.1 has been released, and is supposed to be much improved in terms of usability.
I'm really annoyed with it. 1.4, I ran in a window approximately 1/5th the size of my screen. It was exceptionally easy to navigate and perfectly functional. It was the pick of the players at the time(a few years back), and is very familiar to me.
I understand their reasons for wishing to do a ground-up rewrite - that's fair enough. But the UI is totally different, and needs to be hugely larger than the footprint for 1.4. For me, the middle panel is dead space, and can't be removed. I care little for lyrics.
It can't cope with various-artists albums, throwing them into separate categories for each artist. One time, I just couldn't get it to take in more than ~15% of my music collection(it wasn't a codec issue, or anything like that).
What really got me was... I'm experiencing a delay in volume transition. If I changed it from 10% to 25%, it would take - in all seriousness - 3-4 seconds to adjust.
Much like KDE4, it was released too soon. It lacked important features, absolutely everything was changed, and it was buggy.
Why are they forcing us away from a perfectly working interface, to something totally indifferent from the majority of other players? Would it have been so hard to have two interfaces, or skins? I want a big window with the tracks I've got lined up to play, a collection browser on the left, that I can swap for "content" window to see album art, my most-played tracks by the artist, and other albums in case I fancy continuing my music journey on a familiar path. I want the music control buttons at the bottom, and moveable along the pane. You know what I want? The proven interface that has worked for years now. Amarok was one of the killer-apps on KDE for me. I'm no fan of KDE4, and I despise Amarok 2. I'd learn to find my way around KDE4 now it's somewhat more stable, but Amarok 2 is unfriendly, unintuitive, and just wrong for me. I'm shafted now...
I dare say the Amarok team are doing a fantastic job with the rewrite. But I consider it shameful to change the interface beyond all recognition. And when Googling to try and address the issues I faced, there seemed to be plenty of people who had a similar opinion to mine...
Sorry for going off-topic.
~Phewl.