yazoo123
New Head-Fier
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2013
- Posts
- 39
- Likes
- 12
Quote:
Thanks tkteo for the prompt response,
I do read your point and that's why those (various) encoded CDs could be played on the ordinary CD players/drives.
Having said that, I have a follow-up question:
Putting back to my example, let's say I rip and convert the song "Close to me" from the original 16/44.1 CD version and I get a file named "Close to me_16_44.1.FLAC" (File A) and secondly I rip and convert the same song from 24/192 version and named "Close to me_24_192.FLAC" (File B).
Would these 2 converted files be the same or different, in terms of the audio info and the file size, etc.??
If it is the same, it seems like it's a bit tricky to me that what the recording companies made those various versions?
We know DX100 could display the song info and in this case, would the DX100 display "16 bit 44.1KHz xxx kbps" when I play "File A" and "24 bit 192KHz xxx kbps" when I play "File B" respectively??
Many thanks in advance for clarifying the above. Much appreciated.
Any other expertise have supplementary answers to my questions, if any?
Yazoo, I have purchased XRCD, K2CD, etc from audiophile CD shops, and ripped them to FLAC. We will not extract actual 24/192 or 32 bit audio when ripping these CDs because it is the remastering process that is 24 or 32 bit. But before the audio is pressed onto the actual CD, it is converted to 16-bit 44.1 again.
There are ripping software that can upsample the 16-bit 44.1 from the CD during conversion to FLAC. But my point here is that the CD format whether it is XR, K2, HQ, Linn etc is still going to be 16-bit 44.1 hen it comes to any CD you buy.
Thanks tkteo for the prompt response,
I do read your point and that's why those (various) encoded CDs could be played on the ordinary CD players/drives.
Having said that, I have a follow-up question:
Putting back to my example, let's say I rip and convert the song "Close to me" from the original 16/44.1 CD version and I get a file named "Close to me_16_44.1.FLAC" (File A) and secondly I rip and convert the same song from 24/192 version and named "Close to me_24_192.FLAC" (File B).
Would these 2 converted files be the same or different, in terms of the audio info and the file size, etc.??
If it is the same, it seems like it's a bit tricky to me that what the recording companies made those various versions?
We know DX100 could display the song info and in this case, would the DX100 display "16 bit 44.1KHz xxx kbps" when I play "File A" and "24 bit 192KHz xxx kbps" when I play "File B" respectively??
Many thanks in advance for clarifying the above. Much appreciated.
Any other expertise have supplementary answers to my questions, if any?