HIFIMAN Arya - Arya Stealth - Arya Organic :: Impressions Thread
Oct 11, 2021 at 6:38 PM Post #5,356 of 11,883
Lyr3 is a wonderful amp that you can play with the sound but you have to be ok on just using SE, but if ever plan to get high impedance headphones I would go with the sa 1. I use a gsx mini and for 1/4 the price the singxer came very close to the mini, the only reason I went with the mini is for the bit more resolution and detail that it brought but I would have been just as happy with the sa 1
 
Oct 11, 2021 at 6:45 PM Post #5,357 of 11,883
Lyr3 is a wonderful amp that you can play with the sound but you have to be ok on just using SE, but if ever plan to get high impedance headphones I would go with the sa 1. I use a gsx mini and for 1/4 the price the singxer came very close to the mini, the only reason I went with the mini is for the bit more resolution and detail that it brought but I would have been just as happy with the sa 1
Thats good.. i have hd6xx as well so SA1 is good for both, maybe slightly better if one doesnt want to play with tubes..
 
Oct 12, 2021 at 12:03 AM Post #5,358 of 11,883
- J. Valour mentioned that Jot2 compresses the soundstage.
As far as I remember, he never said that in regards to the soundstage. He refers to dymanic range compression when talking about Schiit amps. It doesn't have anything to do with soundstage. Moreover, he considers this slight dynamic compression as a positive thing for many listeners, whereas he would never say the same thing about losing the soundstage.
 
Oct 12, 2021 at 1:12 AM Post #5,359 of 11,883
As far as I remember, he never said that in regards to the soundstage. He refers to dymanic range compression when talking about Schiit amps. It doesn't have anything to do with soundstage. Moreover, he considers this slight dynamic compression as a positive thing for many listeners, whereas he would never say the same thing about losing the soundstage.
yeah i kinda remembered/mixed up 2 reviews - josh's and passion for sound. What i meant to write was the sound dynamics being compressed and its likely impact on reduced soundstage..
 
Oct 12, 2021 at 2:22 AM Post #5,360 of 11,883
If you ever want a bit more warmth and have a bit of extra cash I highly recommend the fx audio tube 03 or any of the clones for that matter, it's a little tube pre amp with tone controls. It's going to sound like trash right out the gate but if you get decent nos ge tubes and change the op amps it will make you smile every time you use it, especially when you listen to bass heavy music.

The total investment is probably around 100 depending on the op amps but this little device will make the aryas rival the best bass head cans with zero distortion
 
Oct 12, 2021 at 3:29 AM Post #5,361 of 11,883
If you ever want a bit more warmth and have a bit of extra cash I highly recommend the fx audio tube 03 or any of the clones for that matter, it's a little tube pre amp with tone controls. It's going to sound like trash right out the gate but if you get decent nos ge tubes and change the op amps it will make you smile every time you use it, especially when you listen to bass heavy music.

The total investment is probably around 100 depending on the op amps but this little device will make the aryas rival the best bass head cans with zero distortion
already have it..(check DP) 😁
nifty lil device.. ur right about thr bass.. it becomes more textured and extends deep.. using with GE5654 tubes.. With DS dacs, its fantastic.
 
Last edited:
Oct 12, 2021 at 11:12 AM Post #5,363 of 11,883
FYI, I have confirmation from HIFIMAN that the older Arya will NOT be sold alongside the new stealth magnet edition. Manufacturing has moved over completely to the newer version, and all stock remaining of the so-called v2 right now is all that is.

As for naming, it's mostly an SEO thing with retailers and search engines having established the Arya name and a newer name not working out. I don't really agree with this move but there you go. I will still refer to the newer version as HIFIMAN Arya (2021) Stealth Magnet Edition in the full form, and HIFIMAN Arya (2021) as a short form in my upcoming review.
 
Oct 12, 2021 at 1:57 PM Post #5,365 of 11,883
How long has the v3 been selling for (I've seen the stealth edition mentioned all the way back in February) and is anyone working on getting updated measurements for comparison? I'm really curious to see what changes, however small, show up in the FR.
 
Last edited:
Oct 12, 2021 at 3:33 PM Post #5,366 of 11,883
How long has the v3 been selling for (I've seen the stealth edition mentioned all the way back in February) and is anyone working on getting updated measurements for comparison? I'm really curious to see what changes, however small, show up in the FR.
Only since mid-August. The one you are referring to from February was a question about a stealth (as in quiet) update, not Stealth (as in magnets).
 
Oct 12, 2021 at 5:16 PM Post #5,368 of 11,883
I see some debates on whether the stealth magnet version is superior here, I'm just going to post the review I just wrote for them:

TL-DR- Yes they are better, but they are still Aryas. Some people may prefer the old versions, but technically the new one is indeed better. I know it because they reveal some of my mixing mistakes that I previously couldn't hear.

-----------------------------------------

I have been using the OG Arya since 2019 before the pandemic started. As a professional musician, the start of the pandemic meant no more work as a performer. Luckily, I have been working as an audio engineer on the side, and in 2020 saw a huge surge in the demand for my services. The Aryas quickly became a close companion and helped shape many of my best audio works.

After the release of the stealth magnet version this year, I quickly opted for the new version. As soon as I put them on I thought of an analogy- Gandalf the Grey is now Gandalf the White. Still very much the same Gandalf we love, but more powerful, and all-business.

A bit about me- I have been an audiophile since my high school years, having bought my first pair of serious headphones (the humble AKG K240s) after skimping on lunch $$ for a whole semester. In the decade and a half that ensued, I have gone through at least 20 pairs of headphones, if not more. I now work as the founder and director of an early music (baroque) ensemble based in China; I also work as an audio engineer specializing in early music and chamber music in the Netherlands as well China.
A Vivaldi aria performed by my ensemble

I first came in contact with Hifiman through a pair of HE-400i in 2017 and quickly sold my prized Sony SA-5000 after a short comparison. I was hugely surprised that the humble little thing was so balanced in many aspects that I had no regret selling the SA-5000, which truly did shine, but only in a few areas. Needless to say, the Arya was a huge upgrade from the HE-400i in every possible way, and by far the most worthy headphones I have ever had the pleasure to possess- until the new, upgraded version.

Build and comfort

I have no complaints with the build quality, really. They look like headphones Darth Vader would use. The ear cups are deeper and firmer than the OG Arya, which to me is an improvement. I have ears that stick out quite and bit, and these new ear cups prevent them from touching anything. The clamping force is a tad stronger than the first iteration of the Arya, which I also like. Sometimes I would like to move my head around after a few hours at the computer, and it’s nice to know your headphones won’t likely fall off. My only complaint is that the headband is the same plasticy material as the HE-400i. It’s still very comfortable, just not as flashy as the leather headbands on the HE-1000 series. Again, I haven’t paid $3000+ for them either, and I appreciate the trickling down of HE-1000se technology at no increase in cost.

Sound- comparing to other headphones

A lot of Hifiman headphones seem to share a trait, to which the Arya is no exception. Many musician friends would comment on their noise isolating abilities after trying them, and be surprised when I tell them that open headphones do not isolate any noise whatsoever. I would attribute this phenomenon to the vast amount of information delivered by these headphones that immediately occupy the attention of the listener, creating a false sense of noise isolation. The same phenomenon is also true for other models such as the Ananda BT, Deva, and a few Stax systems I have had.

The sound of the stealth magnet version of the Arya can be described as something in between the old Arya and the HE-1000se. This would make sense because the specs of the new Arya has impedance reduced a few Ohms, and sensitivity raised a few dbs (Original Arya 91db, new Arya 94db, HE-1000se 96db). Other than what’s visible on paper, it is clear the magnet size has been slimmed down (hence the “stealth magnet”). Now the green tint of the driver is visible through the space between the magnets, which is kind of cool to look at. I am quite positive this does something positive to the sound- have you tried cupping your hand over open headphones? I guarantee you will not like that sound.

The new Arya inherited many of the traits of the original Arya- the vastness and tallness of the soundstage; the infinite and borderless X, Y and Z-axis; the true-to-life reproduction of instrumental and vocal timbres. The presentation of detail is very likeable; it is not braggy like some of the high-end dynamic headphones from the last decade, but rather presented with a bit of humility, which I consider very classy. The FR has a small dip at 2khz, which to me is a smart design- some headphones such as many of the Stax’s I have auditioned tend to sound shouty on certain instruments and voice types, e.g. a soprano.

It differs from the original Arya in small but meaningful ways- the stealth magnet version is much easier to drive. My old Aryas was never driven to satisfaction from Hifiman’s own HM1000 and 901R’s 4.4mm balanced outputs. The new Aryas sound quite happy with these sources; the bass is certainly fuller, and they never sound congested even while listening to large orchestras. The timbre of the old Arya is mostly retained. I would say they are a touch more transparent too.

The original Arya when compared to the HE-1000se was like an introverted version of his extroverted brother. They were much harder to drive, and sounded a bit distant compared to the “in your face” sensation the HE-1000se could sometimes evoke. The new iteration of the Arya brought it a step closer in the direction of the HE-1000se, while retaining most of the timbre characteristics of the original Arya. It's a tad warmer and more enthusiastic, but not quite like the HE-1000se.

Comparing it to a few Stax systems reveals one big weakness in the tuning of the Stax- they just haven’t done the frequency response right. While Stax systems can sound very smooth and open, there are too many dips and bumps in the FR for me to trust them with any critical tasks. They also tend to get very shouty with sopranos and violins. With the Aryas, I know if something doesn’t sound right, it’s because I haven’t mixed it right.

Unfortunately, I haven’t spent serious time with any version of the Sennheiser HD-800 to comment on how they would compare.


Sound- as a tool for mixing/mastering

Many audio engineers swear by using speakers for mixing and mastering, and I partially agree- unless the problem of HRTF is resolved, headphones will not give you the truest stereo. However, while I use monitors to check imaging and phase, I do most of my mixing on the Arya. Perhaps it would be interesting to know that the Chinese version of Arya often comes with an “audio engineer” designation, which makes perfect sense. In terms of tonal balance, spatial information, and their ultra-sensitive response to EQ, they are very reliable headphones for audio engineers. While you may not want to depend solely on headphones for your final mix and master, they will do 90% of the job, especially while on the move, when bringing a pair of monitors just isn’t an option. With the Aryas I can check the reverb tails, apply EQ, compression, etc with full confidence, and make cuts and edits knowing that if I can’t hear edit-hiccups on the Aryas, no one else can hear them. The other big advantage is the ability to discern subtle differences between microphones and preamps, differences that would definitely be lost on a similarly priced speaker system. As you may know, those subtle differences tend to add up in a recording, and skimping details here and there quickly reduces the overall quality of a recording to unacceptable levels. The closest experience I had that resembled Aryas is a pair of ATC active monitors.

Moving onto the new Aryas- since I did most of my work on the original Aryas, I went through my finished work from this year on the new stealth magnet version. And oh boy, they immediately exposed some of the mistakes I didn’t realize I had made while mixing. I’m not sure whether it’s the new Aryas being more detailed, easier to drive, or both.
Élisabeth Jacquet de la Guerre - Sonata D minor Presto
This was one of my better audio works. Now I realize while the violin was captured great, the harpsichord and viola da gamba could use a bit more detail, and perhaps overall a bit more bass.

The OG Arya definitely could not be driven to satisfaction from headphone jacks of most audio interfaces- it is a shame because the average audio engineer is not the target customer for high-end headphone amps, and the old Arya really needed one to shine. The new version largely solved this problem, and I would be happy to see more audio engineers embracing them as a pair of very reliable workhorse headphones. After all, in today’s world, much of all music is played through headphones. It wouldn’t hurt to have more quality content produced by headphones, for headphones. Here's an all-time favorite of mine, produced by Chesky Records/Steve Guttenberg.
Amber Rubarth - Novocaine
Fantastic review; thanks! Have you ever had the opportunity to hear the Jade 2?
 
Oct 12, 2021 at 9:22 PM Post #5,369 of 11,883
Whoever wants wider soundtage, buy yours today!! 😃 (v2s may not be available)
Sooo, it did contact a retailer (A Head-Fi Sponsor) who had both and specifically ordered the V2/non Stealth version. I went as far as leaving a note on the order saying I wanted the V2, not the Stealth. I also sent an email into customer service for them and received a reply immediately reassuring me that the version I ordered was the V2. My Arya arrived today, I open the box like Ralphie with his Red Ryder, and found the "Stealth Magnets Design" sticker staring back at me in all of it's rainbow hologram glory :scream:

Now I am torn. With all the back and forth on this thread I have gone from second, third, to twelfth guessing myself on trying to get my hands on the V2 before they go away. I have not bought a new pair of cans since 2014 when I bought one of the last LCD-2 before they went fazor. I had it in my head that I wanted to get "out of my head" as much as possible and I came to the conclusion that the V2 would be that. Many here believe that what I have in my possession now is the "superior" version and that it does not give up that much headstage to the V2. Others seem to feel that the V3 Stealth is not an Arya at all. This is torture!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top