It's time I weighed in with my short impressions. I'll begin with a comment I shared under a YouTube review:
"I'm am amazed by my HiBy FC3, using 32-ohm closed headphones. The definition is incredible. In the Sonata line-up, the closest competitor is the E35, which was introduced in the first quarter of 2021. Even so, from the reviews I've seen, the Hiby will sound better. Amazon Prime Music's free MP3s (256 kbps?) are upscaled within Prime, making the FC3's LED quality indicator change from blue to green. Downloaded 16/44.1 FLAC files upscale to green when played in the HibyMusic 4 app."
When I say "the definition is incredible," here's what I mean. In the Broadway musical Anastasia, there's a song called Once Upon a December. Near the end, the song features a large chorus of men and women. Their voices always blended indistinctly as a muddled mess, even when played through my desktop setup: a JDS Labs OL DAC and a DROP O2 amp. But when played through the HiBy from my tablet or phone, the men's voices can be heard distinctly from the women's. There and in other parts of other songs, the HiBy FC3 has been a revelation.
I use mine with a pair of KRK KNS8400 closed headphones on my Huawei Android tablet and my LG V20 phone. Even on the V20, music sounds better. It could be because the HiBy's 9281pro quad DAC is more advanced than the LG's 9018 or 9118 quad DAC. But I suspect it's more that the HiBy has more power, delivering more dynamic range and punch.
I occasionally use my FC3 with my Samsung Tab S4 tablet. But I haven't been able to get the Samsung to allow the FC3's DAC part to work; I'm just getting Samsung sound through the FC3's amp, and the FC3's blue LED never turns green.
I'm toying with the idea of getting a second dongle, to keep on a different floor, attached to different headphones. The FC3 is a safe bet; on Aliexpress, scores of users give it an average rating of 4.9 stars. But being a good Head-Fier, I would always wonder, "What could I have tried instead?" My possible choices are:
- HiBy FC1 ($35 plus shipping from the HiBy store). An incredible value. Same build, same buttons, same LEDs, but with a slightly lesser DAC (a 9270) that can't be as fully programmed and can't play MQA (which I don't use anyway).
- Tempotec Sonata E35 ($80 shipped from U.S. Amazon). The closest competitor. Dual DACs, similar power (80 mW vs. the FC3's 70), and favorably reviewed.
- Trasam DSD ($80 shipped from U.S. Amazon). No reviews, and it uses an even lesser DAC, the 9018K2M--the first of ESS's third-generation DACs, where the 9038 marks the fourth generation. But it uses "an advanced MAX97220 low-pass filter and a new increased LDO Low Dropout Linear Regulator, to further reduce the distortion and noise floor, the signal to noise ratio up to 120dB." More important, it has 120mW per channel at 32 ohms. Among single-ended dongles that cost $100 or less, only the Xduoo Link2 has more (150mW).