Quote:
I know you have said in the past that all remasters you've heard sound better than their previous version and that's fine with me. I completely disagree and find many of them just too compressed and punchy for my tastes, preferring the much wider dynamic range of the earlier masterings. |
Just to clarify, I was comparing modern (last 4-5 years) re-masters to older original issues from the 80s/early 90s. These are almost always better to my ears. OTOH, sometimes, on newer greatest hits collections I have, material from the last 4-5 years does not sound as good as on the actual original issue CDs, so no it's not my experience that a 2003 re-master of stuff originally released in 2000 will automatically always sound better.
I have since found a modern re-master that is almost completely unacceptable to me (and I don't think it's my equipment) which is the recent Bjork Greatest hits. That thing is completely messed up, especially track one. Now *that's* clipping! Yuck!
Quote:
I completely disagree and find many of them just too compressed and punchy for my tastes, preferring the much wider dynamic range of the earlier masterings. |
Well, the other extreme is the hazy, washed out, indistinct, collapsed soundstage, zero instrument separation, soupy sound that you get on a lot of the early CDs. For me, I can't listen to that, it doesn't involve me, it's too distant, indistinct and faded.
Quote:
Remember that last At The Drive-In record? I think I've seen you mention that you like it and so do I but yikes, the compression was horrendous, even though you could still tell that the base recording was pretty good! A shame they felt the need to make it so loud. |
I can see where you're coming from Davey, but I think the whole point of that album is to feel almost like you've been assaulted and pulverized, this is hard-charging, angry rock 'n roll, man!
It's supposed to be punchy! You don't sit back on the divan, sipping your tea and eating your crumpets, and saying, "what a simply ravishing bassline, bravo"!
It's not supposed to be appreciated that way I don't think.
Maybe with the new formats we'll have the best of both worlds-- ability to play huge dynamic peaks without having to pump up the recording!