I think I'll definitely sell the LCD-2C based on just the other headphones I own and their purpose, but I was leaning toward the Verite Open if anything. Any reason you recommend the closed?
Recommended the VC as you don't seem to have a closed headphone in your collection. And while your other headphones cover different timbre and tonality characteristics, the VC is a remarkably balanced headphone. The Verite Open is a phenomenal headphone, but the VC offers similar (and imho better) performance compared to it, all the while bringing you a different experience when compared to the rest of your open headphone collection.
The best thing to do tho is audition all your options. I'm just some dude on the internet, after all! Regardless of what sound advice I can offer, the best advice I can share is to have fun with it. You're about the make a rather large investment, so best to be happy with the choice, no matter what some rando on the forums tells you!