Dear Danny,
Thank you for emailing Creative Technical Support!
If you have purchased two in which the same issue is being displayed,
then it could be that the light, in combination with the plastic, will
give you an appearance of a peachie color, as you mentioned before. I
do not think this is a defect or a problem, unless it's clearly
transparent to the point where you can see it was not intentional. This
is the first time we've heard of this problem, so if you feel that it is
not what you were expecting, then changing it to Red appears to be the
better alternative.