Quote:
Originally Posted by mono /img/forum/go_quote.gif
WTCPT is fixed temp based on the tip? I would not want that, it just causes problems, IMO not be have control over tip temp.
My main point might be that there is no Weller really worth the asking price, these are irons with about a $40 markup for the "Weller" name on them.
|
The WTCPT is closed-loop temperature controlled with the temperature set by a thermostat the tip. It is a very simple mechanical system.
I prefer WTCPT over the Hakko 936.
Changing tips on the Hakko can change calibration. If you forget about this, your tip temprature can be off by a considerable amount.
The Hakko is more fragile. The Hakko manual says not to tap the iron to shake off solder as that can damage it.
The TC201 iron is better balanced than the 907. I find the larger TC201 more comfortable.
I rarely (almost never) need anything besides 700F. I like that I don't have to worry about setting or calibrating the Weller. When I need a different temperature I use my Hakko.
I mostly use my Hakko for surface mount. I use one of my WTCPTs for everything else.
You can get a WTCPT on eBay for very little money. I do agree that the WTCPT isn't $40 better than the Hakko. With HMC's current sale prices the difference is more like $20. At that price difference, I'd base my recommendation on how much surface mount work you plan to do. -- Mostly surface mount get the Hakko. Mostly through hole and cables get the Weller.
Lots of field work, get the Weller. Really need the wider tip selection, get the Hakko.
I've found the two to be complimentary. Sort of like having a big screwdriver and a small screwdriver. If you can afford it, get both!