[AdamCalifornia]

This question has been on my mind for quite a while.
Do you prefer Bon Scott or Brian Johnson?
Would AC/DC be better with Bon Scott if hadn't he died back then?
As we know Bon Scott heard Brian Jonson singing and he liked it.

Upon a time I asked a similar question about Judas Priest:

Do you prefer Judas Priest with Rob Halford or Ripper Owens?

P.S.
Sorry that this is not a poll.

 

[roadtonowhere08]

No contest, Bon Scott.

 

[oak3x]

Bon Scott...easily

 

[epaludo]

As a singer Bon Scott monstly, but have to admit that Brian Johnson does a expectacular job as AC/DC singer. Sometimes i prefer listening to Brian, it depends ...

 

[frankarooney]

Bon Scott, no contest...

 

[lmilhan]

Bon Scott, although I'd be lying if I said I didn't fall in love with the vocals on the Back In Black album back in the day.

 

[.pen.and.ink.]

I'll add to the general consensus. Bon Scott, definitely.

 

[seantx]

No question Bon Scott.

Halford - when in his prime - with Priest. Sadly his voice is gone now.

 

[Zaiks]

As for me Brian Johnson is the voice of AC/DC, can't imagine it be otherwise; still I have a lot of respect for Bon Scott and his contribution to this great band.

 

[kramer5150]

+1 vote for Bon Scott, although not by a landslide. Angus is the main attraction for me... Blazing Marshall JCMs in all their glory. Those guys must be deaf gigging at those stage volumes. From what I understand Angus didn't use dummy cabs, or 1/4 load any of his 4x12s.

 

[Iron_Dreamer]

I'm not a huge AC/DC fan, but Bon Scott has always sounded a lot more passionate to me.

 

[BigJohn]

I heard Brian Johnson a while ago and I commented on how great it was that they found a singer with a similar voice...
But hey I'm 40 years old!

I grew up with Bon as singer from AC/DC!

I liked Bon a lot...
But Brian is alive I think...

So for the moment; Brian gets my vote.

"Live in the present, not in the past"

 

[fordgtlover]

Bon Scott was a great singer, but with Brian Johnson, AC/DC have produced soem of the world's best rock songs.

I think that as singers they are as good as each other. They created great rock, in their own way.

AC/DC is not a better or a worse band for losing Bon Scott, just slightly different.

The problem with great artists dying is that you have no idea whether they would have continued to be great. What would Hendix be doing if he was still alive??? Would he still be the best and coolest guitarist in the world?

 

[bowraboy]

I love Bon's Big Balls.

 

[Blackmore]

Never was a BIG fun of AC/DC but IF YOU WANT BLOOD rules, so Bon Scott all the way