nick_charles
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2008
- Posts
- 3,180
- Likes
- 336
Quote:
Lots of people know lots more about lots of different topics than I do or ever will do. I bow to their superior knowledge and skills when appropriate. Why only today I had to decline to review a conference paper as I did not have sufficient expertise in that subfield, in the words of Dirty Harry "A man's gotta know his limitations".
However magical thinking is still magical thinking however well qualified/educated/skilled/dedicated or even intelligent the puryeror is !
Your posts imply "I can rememeber what it sounded like before" even if the before is days ago. To tell if two things are different you really need a direct comparison like a rapid swich between the two - relying on old memory is really weak evidence unless the differences are gross. When you tell me that two things measure the same but sound different ....well there are numerous possible interpretations, one is that there is some fundamental gap in our world knowledge , one is that the comparsion was badly done (not level matched and so on) and another is that , well you just imagined it - I'm not being rude here - nobody is immune from this !
I see you have a problem with that, that someone actually understands something that you don't, has performed experiments that you haven't that allowed me to gain that understanding.
Lots of people know lots more about lots of different topics than I do or ever will do. I bow to their superior knowledge and skills when appropriate. Why only today I had to decline to review a conference paper as I did not have sufficient expertise in that subfield, in the words of Dirty Harry "A man's gotta know his limitations".
However magical thinking is still magical thinking however well qualified/educated/skilled/dedicated or even intelligent the puryeror is !
Your posts imply "I can rememeber what it sounded like before" even if the before is days ago. To tell if two things are different you really need a direct comparison like a rapid swich between the two - relying on old memory is really weak evidence unless the differences are gross. When you tell me that two things measure the same but sound different ....well there are numerous possible interpretations, one is that there is some fundamental gap in our world knowledge , one is that the comparsion was badly done (not level matched and so on) and another is that , well you just imagined it - I'm not being rude here - nobody is immune from this !