I’ll start with the acknowledgment section, because Tom, Jude and his wife deserve it big time! In fact, I’ll extend my thanks to everybody who participated because the result was such an excellent meet. I am just saying the same thing as others above, but it indeed felt like a (crazy) friends get together. I would suggest that arnett is the craziest of all, actually. Fun time!!
Now for my personal impressions of the gear. It all sucked really bad.
Ok, that’s it for me!
...
No, it did not quite happen this way, c.f. this post title! Actually, my problem was the other way around. I just could not find a dog system at the meet! All the stuff I heard sounded excellent, it was really confusing. Usually, the evaluation is simple when you can say “Oh I liked this one a lot because of this, didn’t like this one because of that...”. But yesterday, I was simply overwhelmed by only good stuff, it was often extremely hard to find minor differences between components. Everybody’s right up there, and a brief listening session in a not so quiet (yeah, you guys are loud!!
) environment made it impossible for me to elect a winner.
Ray Samuel’s tube amp prototype vs. Emmeline HR2 vs. Meier Audio Prehead (LM):
I started with Ray Samuel’s rig. A Meridian 508 hooked up to both his Emmeline HR2 and tube prototype amp. I was eager to listen to this tube amp and was not disappointed. I like the Meridian, owned a 588 for a little while, but sold it because it was not the best synergy in my system (too revealing). With the tube amp driving my stock HD600, I was very pleased. Solid all the way, but not clinical in any way. When I asked Ray about the tubes, I was surprised by his answer... No fancy expensive NOS tubes, all new stock from Russia, affordable ($10-15), but the resulting amp sound was excellent. Plus, this amp looks gorgeous even though it’s still at the prototype stage.
I briefly did an A/B against the HR2 and later on the Prehead (LM version) using a A/B switch that Ray had built, which enabled to make comparisons between amps using the same headphone. I found the HR2 a little less forgiving in the Meridian setup and much preferred the tube prototype. The tube amp had more weight, sounded fuller and richer in the bass region although not a thick sound by any mean. It was still very solid!
The Prehead against the tube amp yielded similar conclusions, solid state amps thus sounded overall thinner compared to the tube prototype. Now, as I said above, differences were really hard to pick up, it was not jumping at you. No way to judge for low level detail so these comparisons are only so good...
SinglePower MPX3 with brand new Hytrons vs. Meier Audio Prehead (LM version):
Next, I went into the world of Mikhail from SinglePower. Arnett had hooked up his MPX3 with new Hytrons tubes to my Jolida CDP. I again used Ray’s A/B switch to compare the MPX3 to my Prehead still using the stock HD600s. Well, with this Jolida source, I was very hard pressed to find differences between the Singlepower and Meier Audio amps although I was switching back and forth between the two instantaneously. This is to me the easiest way to pick up differences between components. But I realized that, once the loudness is matched, it was impossible to assign a color to any of the two amps.
Now, I believe this Jolida CDP is far from revealing. That is the reason why I bought it in the first place actually... I wanted an easy going system that let me enjoy both my good and not so good recordings. The Meridian wanted to be treated with excellent recordings, the Jolida is way more tolerant although way less precise I believe. So, my point is this was probably not the best source to A/B the amps...
Wadia’s high end separate transport / DAC with the latest supercharged SinglePower Supra:
Later on, I had the pleasure to listen to the super duper Supra that Mikhail had brought. At every meet, he brings a new, bigger amp. I am afraid that for the upcoming Chicago meet, his latest amp won’t pass through the doors or will require 4 heavy men to lift it
. This beefed up Supra was hooked to the best of the best of Wadia’s gear and well, it did sound up to the premise... That is the rig that made me smile big time when I threw my CDs at it using the HD600/Equinox cable. Arhhhhhh, it was just sooo good! No description there, just this big smile, pounding heart when you turn the music on. Mikhail modestly told me that the amp simply “amplifies” what it is fed with, no more. Well, I don’t know who was responsible for it but it sounded like what I am looking for (although for less $ $ $
). Those of you out there who are looking for a no compromise source, please check out Wadia’s gear, it’s got to be among the few best in the world!!!
Supercharged SinglePower Supra vs. Meier Audio Prehead (AD version):
When the Headroom Blockhead was switched with the Singlepower amp, I hooked it up to my Jolida CDP. I used Ray’s A/B switch once again to compare the high end Singlepower to Jude’s Prehead (AD version) with some HD600/Equinox. Again, the differences between the two amps were really not dramatic. Somehow, the tube amp sounded a little thick and sloppy in the bass region compared to the Prehead. It was just a slightly bit warmer but not much. The magic I had experienced with the Wadia source was actually gone... So this was probably the confirmation that the Jolida is not really a proper source to benchmark amps!!
Meier Audio Prehead (AD vs. LM version):
The last test I did was to compare the two versions of the Prehead amp (LM vs AD chip) in my rig (Jolida CDP / HD 600). What I found out is that the AD version (Jude’s amp) had this very slightly fuller, richer sound with a little less sparkle than the LM version which I own. And, you may have noticed by now, one of my goals at this meet was to compare my amp to other ones in the hope of finding something just as clean and detailed, but more forgiving at the same time... It turns out that I went back home with Jude’s amp, we switched units at the meet! Thanks again Jude for your offer and please let me know if you feel you made a mistake when trading your AD version, I’ll bring it back to you.
Jude’s ASL Twinhead home rig:
I had a listen to Jude’s home rig, the ASL TwinHead, Sony SACD drive / Bel Canto DAC2. Wow, this was good! At the previous HeadFi meet in Ann Arbor, I had really not been impressed with the ASL TwinHead. I mean it was good, but not up to my level of expectations. Yesterday, I found Jude’s rig excellent. Once again, no much description, you are just enjoying the music, free from all this equipment debate!!! Congratulations Jude, you have a very unique system there!
Headroom Blockhead / Wadia prototype CDP / HD600 with balanced Cardas:
It was very brief, too brief. I had the same feeling as with Jude’s rig. The music is flowing, effortlessly, you just enjoy, point. Unfortunately, I was driven my more down to earth prices, being in the market for a new amp, so I did not spend enough time to judge this awesome rig...
Elrod Tom’s rig: AKG K1000 / Norh (sp.?) integrated tube amp / modded Pioneer unit:
This was also brief. I was afraid of a bright sound, maybe harsh with my CDs. It was not harsh at all. This rig sounds very good, so different from everything else. I guess everybody knows it, but this is the rig for people who get claustrophobic with regular headphones and dig for electrostatic kind of detail and transparency. My guess is that Elrod-Tom put a lot of effort to make a complementary system and it overall sounds very pleasing.
Phillips 963 / Wheatfield Audio HA-1 (or 2?):
This was even more brief... Not that I did not like it, it’s just that my goals were somewhere else. From the 2 minutes I listened to it with stock HD600, it sound fine to me, no striking default.
Well, I think this is about it for me. As you can see, there was just too much equipment at this meet!!! I think Jude’s Air Conditioning also had a hard time keeping up with the heat buildup in the basement
. A wonderful meet!
Arnaud.