I Picked up the Box Set as well and I truly enjoyed the DVD. I listened to the surround 5.1 mix of the album and watched every video bit. While at a first listen, it seems there's nothing captivating about SOTU, if you listen a bit more, you will find some great songs in there. I liked the Wrong video, it feels like watching a clip of a SAW movie, very different than any other video they have done. The Studio session tracks are very good, to me these versions sound a lot better than the album versions. They should release the whole album recorded this way, there are more dynamics and warmth to the sound. For example; the song 'Come back' in the album has this distorted guitar sound all over the track that totally destroys it, making the song annoyingly unlistenable! If you listen to the Studio Session version on the DVD, this songs excels, Martin plays the piano here instead of the distorted guitar, giving the song a more acoustic sound. The Bonus tracks are excellent, worth listening too. I really enjoyed 'Stories of Old and 'Ghost' great classic DM songs IMO. The demos CD is a good addition to the Pack, it shows you how Martin 1st envisioned the songs(all sung by Gore) although not sung with much emotion, and minimal instrumentation is present, still very good indeed. The remixes CD is pretty good and the art book with lyrics, photography and extra goodies like the pin badges, postcards are nice in a "collectors', and True fan" kind of sense. So I pretty much enjoyed the Box set as a whole, I wouldn't say this is their worst work nor their best, but I think they are playing it toooo safe. Then again DM don't have anything to prove to anybody, so they can do whatever they want and not be concerned about losing anything. I have to listen to the album a bit more in order to be assertive about its quality, but as of now, I'd say it is safe to say that SOTU it's definitely more suited for a true DM fan. Listen to it, draw your own conclusions, and see how it fits within your musical tastes. As far as my own tastes with DM, I've always have these albums as my top 5 in the following order:
'Songs of Faith & Devotion'
'Violator'
'Music for the Masses'
'Ultra'
'Black Celebration'