OK, things has changed a bit since i last posted this thread, mostly my understanding
it's amazing how much knowledge you can get here. well, to the point:
i bought the ART DI/O DAC, as it's very upgradable and can be really better then almost every soundcard setup, as i see it: i wanted to get rid of possible hardware noise.
you can make the mods yourself, just dig the information. at $100 for the basic unit (
http://www.fullcompass.com/ ) there is no better deal to be found, considering that your setup won't be computer limited!
hardcore ART modifiers report reaching very high level with that device. you will probably invest in a digital cable too (you can get for $30 a 1m DIY Belden 1695A cable from Paul Harnagel (copycatcables@yahoo.com), which is considered to work very good and sound better). you can check out the main FAQ's:
http://home.ca.inter.net/~cfraser/DIOFAQ.htm
http://www.angelfire.com/ca/rchau/audio.html#DI/O
next: the coaxial output device: i don't want to get into that optical-> coaxial convereters, just USB straight to coaxial output.
i have found 2 devices that had coax out, and you get the extra of the optical out for your MD, so you can listen with coax and record with optical. here they are, standing at about $80:
Xitel Pro Hi-Fi Link:
www.xitel.com
and the cheapest price to get is:
http://www.provantage.com/buy-110XIT...l-shopping.htm
well, for us, its RCA outputs are useless, as the DAC part of the device ain't good even as a sonica, as Wodgy says. you also get long cables..i think this is useless for us.
Edirol UA-1D: just search that on Ebay.
here you get coax and optical inputs and outputs! sweeeet. i can find a good use of digital inputs for recording to the computer.
BUT: we have the LOCKING issue with a DAC, and the ART is known to be a bit sensitive.
response from Xitel support:
Quote:
Always primed with clock data; It means that the digital engine is always outputting a stream of clock data. S/PDIF is bi-phase encoded, consisting of a clock stream and content stream. By transmitting the clock stream continually an external DAC can acquire a lock before the content is transmitted. |
mac users: Quote:
Depends on what OS you're using. If you're running OS9.X or a version of OS10 prior to 10.2, the OS sends a priming stream of clock data continuously. In OS10.2 and above, the signal is sent as biphase encoded S/PDIF only when a track is playing. |
OTOH, Edirol tech team hasn't respond to me, but has responded to Audiosyncrazy (the Ebay prime seller ATM), and says it's doesn't send a constant signal, and that's why it won't lose a lock! sounds fishy... but Audiosyncrazy told me that if the device is useless for me, they will take it back and fully refund my money (exept delivery).
what do you guys say? which 1 should i go for?
and another thing - as i read, i understand that when we use a CDP, the sound quality is also affected by the accuracy of the spinning engine and other internals. could it be that :
Exact Ausio Copy ripps to lossless file format (HD reading)->USB Coaxial output
will be better then DVD/SACD/whatever that reads a disc with Coaxial output ?
will the USB be the bottleneck? what else?
should we consider the device with the shorter USB cable in that case? does the power supply issues also affects the digital out?