Don't know the Storyhill guys but I do sometimes know a good acoustic folk album when I hear it, and Gillian Welch did a very good one a few years ago in 2001 called
Time (the Revelator) that's still one of my favorites, and very nice sounding too. Recorded simply, live in the studio with just a couple of Neumann mikes, Gillian and David, banjo and vintage acoustic guitars, and a lot of good music. Gillian describes the album, "As opposed to little tiny folk songs, they're really tiny rock songs performed in an acoustic setting. In our heads we went electric without changing instruments."
The new Holopaw is mostly acoustic and a real nice one, as is their debut. Some electronic textures to light up the background though, kind of like Califone, whose
Roomsound is a big favorite of mine. Nice recording too. Nina Nastasia
The Blackened Air is a big favorite, and a very nice Steve Albini production so you know it sounds nice. Agree about Palace/Palace Brothers/Will Oldham/Bonnie Prince Billy. Love
Viva Last Blues. One of those recs I'll probably keep pulling out until the day I nod off for good. Maybe not everybody's cup of folk, but works for me. Iron and Wine? Mountain Goats? Devendra Banhart? First Vashti Bunyan in 35 years just came out and I wanna hear that, backed by Devendra and Joanna Newsome. Richmond Fontaine? The new one called
The Fitzgerald is stellar and along the same lines as that
Nebraska jhambone mentions. Want more, got a bunch? You like it happy or sad? If melancholy rules check out Damien Jurado and his
Where Shall You Take Me. And Nick Drake
Pink Moon