So I figured I'd take one for the team (I've lurked here long enough and figured I should probably contribute). This won't be a long review, or anything; I just want to supply my thoughts on a brief listening. I'm currently pushing them through the following setup:
27" MacBook Pro running Tidal
USB to McIntosh MHA100
The MHA100 is set to 8 - 40 ohms, as the only info I could find on Amazon headphones impedance was with the premium headphones, at 16 ohms.
For reference, my usual setup for listening to music at my desk is the MHA100 with Audeze LCD-XCs, Audeze EL-8s closed back, or V-Moda M100s.
I'm going to say this in spite of myself; I'm damn impressed. Punchy bass and decent treble, I'm really really surprised. While these are clearly tuned to pop and hiphop fans - the bass is heavy out of the box and the mids are a little more flat than I'm usually comfortable with, treble was nice and clear while with a fairly open soundstage.
Physically, they don't feel like the best headphone you can buy. Not. Even. Close. If anything, they feel closer to cheap airplane headphones. That said, the audio quality is much improved.
I did notice, while playing Beyoncé's Drunk in Love, when the bass kicks in, there's some residual buzz in mids and highs because the bass is so deep. In the end, I had to take the low end down a bit, because it was overpowering mids and highs. Alternatively, activating McIntosh's HXD feature helped significantly, although I'm not usually a fan of Crossfeed.
I played a few tracks with these:
Beyoncé - Drunk in Love
C2C - The Beat
Cake - Italian Leather Sofa
Brad Mehldau - Blackbird
Melody Gardot - Mira
Overall thoughts. Over. All. Thoughts. Hmm. Would I buy these as a gift for someone? Hell no. I have too much self respect for that. They look and feel like I fell out of a United Airlines storage room belowdeck with my carryon full of cheap paraphernalia. That said, would I bring them with me if I were going someplace I'd fear them getting stolen? Or broken? Or ruined? Absolutely. would I recommend them to someone else? Sure! $14.99? No problem. I would personally like to see Amazon dial back the low end a bit, as it seriously overpowers the mids and highs, and it'd be nice if they'd work on improving the mids a bit, as they seem a bit flat. They also seem a bit sluggish, although not annoyingly so. That said, slow can be nice for certain types of music.
Either way, I give them a solid B+/A- for $15 headphones. Now I want to hear the premium version.