Hello all!
I've been lurking and posting here and there for a little while now, preparing to make my first 'real' purchase. I'm thinking Oppo PM-3 and the HA-2 to go with it.
However, today I got the chance to try out a bunch of really high end headphones and amps. I tried the Audeze LCD3, Audeze LCD2, Beyerdynamic T1, Grado PS1000, and some others. I had my iTunes hooked up via USB to a Lavry DA11 DAC, and I tried the Amp in the DA11, a Phonitor 2730B, and some sort of old gigantic Moth Audio tube amp (from some googling, it looks similar to the S45, but not exactly).
Here's the thing though, all of these amps sounded pretty much the same to me, no matter which headphones I used. Additionally, all of these headphones sounded pretty similar as well. I honestly couldn't tell the difference between the LCD2 and the LCD3 at all. There was a little bit of difference between the T1 and the Audeze's and the PS1000, but honestly if someone were to blindfold me, I don't think I would be able to identify which headphone was which (except for of course the feeling of the ear pads).
So naturally, my next reaction was maybe my sources were just bad (mp3's between 256 and 320 kbps). So, I hooked up the LCD3, and then opened the Tidal Hifi test
here and gave it a try. I took it maybe 3 or 4 times, and each time, I literally could not tell any difference between any of the A and B samples. Through best-effort-guessing, I managed a 3/5, 2/5, 1/5, and 4/5 in four different attempts, which leads me to believe this is just pretty random luck, and getting better (lossless) sources won't make a difference for me.
I can tell that all of these headphones are definitely *way better* than my Bose QC15 or M50's, but that's largely due to just clarity/lack of distortion. I'm not hearing any adjectives like 'warm' or 'smooth' or 'bright' among the high end ones. I put them on and all I can say is "yep. these are good."
Are my ears just not sensitive enough to be an audiophile? What am I supposed to be listening for? Or is it really that the entire hobby just about obsessing over that 1% difference?