Well…. It happened eventually, I bought the Elrog 274b (the Aegis side lamp). It’s been running for just over 60 hours now and feel like I can compare it with the Mullard GZ34 & Brimar 5R4GY, my other two favourite rectifier tubes with the Aegis.
In simple terms, the Elrog 274b is like a refined Mullard GZ34 that had a love child with a Brimar 5R4GY. It has the detail of the GZ34 but sweeter highs, mids and it has the texture of the Brimar 5R4GY but with more low end weight / impact (especially with AC). I think the warmth of the Brimar 5R4GY extends a little further towards the mids than the Elrog though.
Words that came to mind when listening to the Elrog 274b: expansiveness - all directions, detail, transparent… very, texture, great pace… very agile. Imaging and layering feels really precise….and weight, authority. It’s not a dry sound, sweet and musical I would say. But big, extends all directions.
My two standout combos...
Atrium Closed, Elrog 274b, Mullard EL38 & RCA Red Base 5691.
Listening to electronic & EDM genres with this load out was really fun but it also felt special in that it was smooth and refined with weight and detail. Open with a nice out of head / headphones sound to it going in all directions (great depth). It felt pacy, energetic in a foot tapping arms waving type of way… just great fun. When you focused on the details, it was very easy to track sounds around the stage and when sounds moved, it felt smooth... all very 3 dimensional. I’m looking forward to listening to other genres with this combo.
Meze Elites, Elrog 274b, GEC KT88 & RCA Red Base 5691.
Listening to classical and acoustic it provided an effortless big soundstage that was rich in tone and texture… solid 3 dimensional sound that seemed to radiate all around, air without sounding thin. Imaging was very precise, you could easily make out where each musician was playing from and the movement of sound within the stage. A big effortless sound. When I swapped out the GEC KT88 for the EL38 with classical, I missed some of the weight and richness that the KT88 provide, it felt like the EL38 tipped the balance a little to far towards the highs with the Elrog for classical. Very listenable still but I prefer the Brimar 5R4GY + EL38 for that genre with the Meze Elites.
When removing the Elrog and popping the GZ34 back in, I felt like I missed the expansiveness… felt more side to side and less spherical in terms of soundstage. A bit more grain, not as smooth in the mids and highs and of course not as much bass impact. The Brimar has great warmth and texture but misses the detail, highs of the Elrog… less expansive feeling. The EL38's help provide the extra detail, stage for the Brimar and it's a combo I really like.
So, the Elrog 274b is a very nice tube that shines (literally) but it is damed expensive. Would I recommend it…. Yes BUT, only if you have all the power & input tubes you want. You could buy a pair of RCA Red Base 5691, Mullard GZ34 (normal not metal base), Brimar 5R4GY CV717, a pair of Mullard EL38’s and a very nice bottle of single malt and still have some change from the cost of the Elrog! And if you don’t have any of those tubes, that’s where I’d recommend the money be spent first! Just makes more sense.
But… if you already have all that and more (power purification etc) and want something a little special and could do with an extra light in your listening room… go for it. I’ll certainly be replacing it when the time comes