mono
1000+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2005
- Posts
- 1,412
- Likes
- 11
Having gotten a couple hours sleep since first playing with my adapter, I reconsider that the circuit I previously proposed and constructed may not be suitable "as-is" for battery charging, for two primary reason:
1) It makes the assumption that the cells used have enough internal resistance that the current delivered is less than transformer is capable of. If your cells cause enough current to be drawn the voltage will drop below the 9V + X (regulator vDrop) and the circuit won't be stable. It will charge batteries but in a test it caused a slight ~ 0.025V AC ripple. A resistor in series on the output and an adjustment to the regulator's output may resolve this.
2) Upon reaching the timer's shutoff point, you'd then have batteries continually at higher potential, voltage on the output of the regulator. An inline diode would fix this, or a more elaborate circuit, but as is, it's less than ideal... though LM1085 supposedly has some protection in this regard it still isn't a good design for this reason.
However, I may just leave mine as-is and try it... if anything goes POOF or BOOM I'll report back.
Edit: Went through one complete charge cycle with some manually, almost fully drained pack of 6 x 1800mAH AA NiMH cells. They appear fully charged (though I've not tested resultant capacity as I didn't even know what their capacity would've been through alternate charge methods, only their rated spec). I'd wondered if the 'sink on the regulator was necessary, especially since it required cutting out a small rectangular hole in the wart's casing. For higher voltage or powering a small amp it may not be but for this charging test it certainly seemed necessary as the 'sink got pretty warm.
Above as #2 I'd mentioned battery potential above regulator. Indeed after the "charger's" timer had shut it off there was ~ 40mA of current backflowing into it from the batteries. No POOF or BOOM though, regulator withstood the backflow of current and whole thing still works. I may take this circuit out of the adapter, tweak it and put it into one of several other wall-warts I have that can sustain > 300mA @ 9V, as the peak current for charging this AA pack was a little under 300mA (below 9V though), don't recall exact figure but maybe 260mA. 260 puts it close to the VA 2.2W capability I'd speculated about previously too, so it seems 2.2W is a good conservative estimate for this transformer. In summary circuit works but might be better suited as cheap headamp supply, still sub-optimal for battery charging as originally configured.
1) It makes the assumption that the cells used have enough internal resistance that the current delivered is less than transformer is capable of. If your cells cause enough current to be drawn the voltage will drop below the 9V + X (regulator vDrop) and the circuit won't be stable. It will charge batteries but in a test it caused a slight ~ 0.025V AC ripple. A resistor in series on the output and an adjustment to the regulator's output may resolve this.
2) Upon reaching the timer's shutoff point, you'd then have batteries continually at higher potential, voltage on the output of the regulator. An inline diode would fix this, or a more elaborate circuit, but as is, it's less than ideal... though LM1085 supposedly has some protection in this regard it still isn't a good design for this reason.
However, I may just leave mine as-is and try it... if anything goes POOF or BOOM I'll report back.
Edit: Went through one complete charge cycle with some manually, almost fully drained pack of 6 x 1800mAH AA NiMH cells. They appear fully charged (though I've not tested resultant capacity as I didn't even know what their capacity would've been through alternate charge methods, only their rated spec). I'd wondered if the 'sink on the regulator was necessary, especially since it required cutting out a small rectangular hole in the wart's casing. For higher voltage or powering a small amp it may not be but for this charging test it certainly seemed necessary as the 'sink got pretty warm.
Above as #2 I'd mentioned battery potential above regulator. Indeed after the "charger's" timer had shut it off there was ~ 40mA of current backflowing into it from the batteries. No POOF or BOOM though, regulator withstood the backflow of current and whole thing still works. I may take this circuit out of the adapter, tweak it and put it into one of several other wall-warts I have that can sustain > 300mA @ 9V, as the peak current for charging this AA pack was a little under 300mA (below 9V though), don't recall exact figure but maybe 260mA. 260 puts it close to the VA 2.2W capability I'd speculated about previously too, so it seems 2.2W is a good conservative estimate for this transformer. In summary circuit works but might be better suited as cheap headamp supply, still sub-optimal for battery charging as originally configured.