Reviews by Tronz
Pros: Amazing Sound!, External SD Card Slot, User Removable Amplifier, 24/96khz support.
Cons: Poor Battery Life, Clunky Footprint, Fingerprint and Scratch Magnet, Glitchy User Interface.
 
Hifiman HM-801
 
Disclaimer: This review is just a reflection of my opinions and experience.
 ​
2009Jul21164012001.jpg
 ​
 
Specifications:
  1. Modular Design: Modular Amplifier Bay (Named GanQi Bay) and 14.8 volt Lithium Polymer Battery Bay
  2. Memory: SDHC Card 
  3. DAC function: Coaxial (44.1kHz, 96 kHz) , USB DAC (16bit, 48kHz)
  4. DAC Chip: Burr-Brown PCM1704U-K (for Player, Coaxial and USB) ; Op-Amp: OPA627
  5. Size: 114 mm *78mm * 25.5 mm or 4.49 * 3.07 * 1.00 Inch
  6. Output: Headphone out; Line out
  7. Exchangeable Module Battery Life : 7 to 8 hours (Depending upon which Modular Amplifier board is mounted)
 
Contents in Packaging:
  1. HM-801 Player
  2. 110v AC to 18v 2000mA charger
  3. USB cable
  4. Coaxial cable
  5. Philips screwdriver
  6. Microfiber cloth
  7. Carrying pouch
 
SDC10488.jpgSDC10506.jpg
 
 
User Interface:
 
The Hifiman HM-801 has a very basic and straight to the point UI. With a very small color LCD display and 5 circular buttons located beside it, immediately you get the idea that this player isn't about modern day bells and whistles typically found in the latest Cowon player or Apple iPod Touch. The HM-801 also has 4 buttons at the top of the unit. The 4 buttons are the power button, skip back or reverse button, skip forward or fast forward button and the play and pause button for quick and easy accessibility to your music without having to look at the screen. Alongside the screen, are the "at first" awkwardly presented 5 buttons that are responsible for navigating through the HM-801's UI. The top 2 buttons are the back and forward buttons. They allow you to leave a menu screen or advance further into the menu. The single button in the menu is your "select" button. This button confirms a selection. The bottom 2 buttons are the up and down buttons which navigates the selector up or down. Like I said before, at first they're a bit awkward, but after awhile they become second nature and you will fly through the UI. The UI isn't without flaws though. There isn't a "search" option and the overall response time of the buttons and the menu is sluggish. There are several bugs such as the device sometimes freezing to the point where the battery needs to be completely removed and placed back in. You select a song and a completely different song begins to play. You're scrolling down the list of your songs and the device begins to play a song randomly. These are very small problems that don't hinder the ability to use the device, but they're still problems that I hope get fixed down the road. 
 
Adding music to the HM-801 is very simple. Either plug the SDHC card directly into your computer and copy the music files over or plug the HM-801 up to your computer via a USB cable and also have access to the built in 2gb's of storage for upgrading the firmware or music storage. The HM-801 also acts as a USB or Coaxial based DAC. Personally, I found the sound quality to slightly suffer when doing this ( haven't tried coaxial), but it still outperforms the sound quality out of my laptop's 3.5mm headphone out. Surprisingly, there is a 5 band equalizer in the HM-801's UI though it has done more harm than good in my opinion. 
 
The UI for the HM-801 can be upgraded to the Rockbox firmware which allows the HM-801 to finally have gapless support as well as a bunch of new features. As of now, the Rockbox firmware for the HM-801 is in a very un-stable form and the support to improve it's stability doesn't seem to be growing unfortunately...
 
 
Build Quality:
 
Despite being manufactured by a small company in China, the build quality is very good.  It's not as good as say something as mass produced as an iPod, but it doesn't look like it will fall apart on it's own over time. Even though it's essentially a "brick", it's a sleek looking brick in my opinion. The shiny back metal with the gold accents really give it a serious look. If you've grown up using Walkmans, you'll grow to appreciate the HM-801 aesthetically even more. The main gripes that I have with the HM-801 in terms of the build is that it's both a finger print and scratch magnet thanks to the type of material used for the exterior. The scratches aren't easily noticeable in normal lighting, but when you take it under intense light such as outside, the scratches really begin to show themselves and annoy you. Also, the gold paint on buttons will wear off over time.
 
 ​
SDC10684.jpgSDC10678.jpg
 
 
Battery Life:
 
With such power hungry components jammed into this thing such as the PCM1074UK and OPA627 chips, the battery must be able to deliver a lot of voltage and current. The HM-801's battery life is rated at around 7-8 hours. I get roughly the same times too. This player needs to be strapped down by it's charger every night if you're planning to frequently use it during the day. Purchasing another battery can extend the potential time you have with the HM-801 to 14-16 hours. Also, I wanted to note, the HM-801 itself warms up during music playback and warms up a bit further during charging. The AC charger also gets warm too which is expected of any charger giving out so much power in DC. The HM-801 will not charge via a USB cable simply because of the low power output, but surprisingly, the menu can still be navigated with only power from a USB cable. No music will play from a USB cable though.
 
 ​
SDC10674.jpgSDC10675.jpg
 ​
 
Sound Quality:
 
With everything else aside, we approach the most important aspect of the player, the sound quality. The only thing I've used to listen to this player was my Westone ES5's. The amplifier module inside this unit is the Standard v2 amp. I did not use any external portable or desktop amplifiers with the HM-801 during this review. The majority of my music is FLAC with about 30% of it being 256-320kbps MP3. The portable mp3 player I will be comparing the HM-801 to is the iPod Touch 3G.
 
The HM-801 has a warm, euphoric and spacious sound. To those who prefer a more accurate and linear presentation, this player may not be your cup of tea. Compared to my iPod, the iPod has more lively and energetic sound mainly due to the lack of lower and upper treble roll off. This is just frequency response alone. As we step out away from that and approach detail retrieval capabilities, texturing, soundstage and realism, the iPod simply cannot hold a candle. The iPod sounds hazy, muddy, cold and lifeless compared to the HM-801. I never thought muddy and cold could be associated with each other when describing sound, but the iPod changed my assumptions.
 
Bass:
 
The HM-801's bass is very bold and powerful. Not, overly so, but enough to add a nice foundation to your music. I can much more easily hear different bass notes as they simultaneously play. The bass extension far exceeds my iPod which made me think my Westone ES5's just didn't have the extension capabilities I expected. Plugged into the HM-801, my Westone ES5's pumps out bass that I would seriously expect from a full size dynamic driver headphone. With such a present and authoritative bass, the rest of the music is surprisingly left unharmed. The bass not only hits harder, but with a more sharper and tighter focus behind every hit. This is a result of the higher power output that the HM-801 can easily supply. The iPod's bass punch isn't terribly bloated or boomy, but it's just not as vivid and focused as the HM-801. The HM-801 has no mid-bass bloat, just a nicely presented, linear bass presentation that will sure bring out the best in your subwoofer.  
 
Midrange: 
 
There seems to be a slight forwardness to the midrange presentation of the HM-801. Surprisingly, it doesn't make it too fatiguing since the Westone ES5 themselves too have a forward midrange. Vocals on the HM-801 have such a natural weight and presence to them I cannot find in the iPod. It's easy to just sit back and admire the instruments through the HM-801 while through the iPod, I become analytic and pin-point every flaw, mainly vocal sibilance. The vocals through the iPod have a lifeless and sucked out presentation that really hurts the musical enjoyment for me. The coherence between the lower midrange and upper midrange is also poor on the iPod. When the vocalist pronounces anything that is likely to cause sibilance, the actual sibilant note seems to be higher in db than the lower harmonic notes. Through the same song, with the HM-801, the voices sound a lot more smoother, vivid and realistic. Guitars have such a beautiful presence and the overall power behind every instrument is easily felt. Due to the HM-801's improved midrange clarity, even though I'm less critical/analytical while listening to the HM-801, I can understand what the vocalist are saying a lot easier than through my iPod. 
 
Treble:
 
Smooth, precise and natural is the words I'd use to describe the HM-801's treble. The iPod has more emphasis here, which in my opinion, gives it that hazy, cold and lifeless sound. Some may call it the "digital" sound. At first, this sound is exciting, but after a while, it becomes fatiguing. The HM-801 has gotten a lot of hate because of it's treble roll off. It's okay that you want the most accurate source according to graph sheets, but in terms of musical enjoyment and realism, neutral isn't the sound you most likely want. Though the HM-801 has less treble energy than the iPod, it still manages to produce a larger soundstage with a more detailed and fine tuned imaging. Every note carries a convincing weight and presence that is non-existent with the iPod. The sense of ambiance is absolutely breathtaking with the HM-801 along with an even darker background than the iPod. Simply put, the treble and overall sound from the HM-801 is just effortless. 
 
 
SDC10763.jpgSDC11101.jpg
 
 
 
Summary:
 
The Hifiman HM-801 isn't the end be it all audiophile DAP. It still has it's share of flaws that keeps it from being #1 just like any other mp3 player. To some, this player may seem like a giant waste of money or a marketing scam. In my opinion, if you love music, have high end IEM's or portable headphones and want to upgrade your portable source, take a more in-depth look at the HM-801. The HM-801 is an exceptionally great sounding DAP with a powerful built in amplifier that can drive a wide range of full sized headphones to a respectable degree and a legendary built in DAC that is highly regarded as one of the best DAC's ever created. I'm glad I took the dive and bought this DAP.
 
Highly recommended! 
smily_headphones1.gif

budgetboy
budgetboy
Great review, especially with the comparison with the ipod and using westone es5's. Someday, when I get the money, this is probably on my list
Tronz
Tronz
Thanks budgetboy.
landroni
landroni
Pros: Breathtaking Sound Quality, Perfect Fit, Superb Noise Isolation, Top Notch Build Quality and Removable Cables!
Cons: None that I can think of...
Westone ES5

Disclaimer:  This review is just a reflection of my opinions and experience.
 ​
ES520Pinot20Noir20540x490_0.jpg
Specifications:

Sensitivity: 120 dB SPL/mW
Frequency response: 8 Hz - 20 kHz
Impedance: 20 ohm
Speaker Technology: Five balanced armature drivers with a passive three-way crossover
Features : Replaceable cable, one year parts and labor warranty on internal components, 25 dB average noise attenuation, user manual and deluxe carrying case

Equipment Used In This Review:

Hifiman HM-801
iPod Touch 3G
iPhone 4
Sansa Fuze
Macbook Pro
 



Introduction
    
 ​
      Before I had the pleasure of listening to the Westone ES5's I went through a obstacle. My first pair of quality IEM's back in 2006 was the Etymotic ER4P. Coming from a bunch of cheap earbuds, canal phones and clip on sports headphones the ER4P really surprised me at how much I was missing. The ER4P's are one of the top monitors in the universal IEM arena when it comes to detail and clarity. The soundstage isn't that great, more on the slightly below average level, but the instrument seperation is very sharp and distinct. I was very happy with the ER4P's until I lost them while coming home from work. Whoever found them, I hope you can experience their wonderful detail and clarity. I couldn't go back to my previous earbuds, earphones, etc... So I decided to look for a better universal IEM and came across the Westone 3.
 

      The Westone 3's were like the polar opposite of the ER4P and it took me a while to get accustomed to the 3's. My first reaction to the sound of the 3's was " Oh gawd, the bass!!! ". Though the bass was no doubt tight and detailed it was well beyond it's wanted presence. In some songs the added bass was welcoming, but in other songs it ruined the whole balance. Usually speakers that have this much bass output don't have great clarity or detail to their overall sound. The Westone 3's really changed that general thought for me. It's sound is very detailed and clear. The midrange was slightly laid back and sometimes a bit harsh, but it was nicely presented most of the time. The treble was sometimes a bit too hot and really induced listening fatigue quickly. This was on poorly mastered recordings though and never really did this on my reference ones. To me the ER4P's were a bit clearer and detailed, but the Westone 3's had a MUCH larger soundstage and musical characteristic feel to the sound.
 

      I ended up selling my Westone 3's in preparation for purchasing a custom IEM. Now that I think about it, I should have kept my Westone 3's as a back up IEM... I visited a few audiologists in NY and got to listen to Jerry Harvey's custom IEM's ( JH13 Pro, JH11 Pro and JH10 pro ). I actually had my mind set on the JH13 Pro, because the sound was just spectacular on so many levels. It was like the Etymotic ER4P and Westone 3 had a baby and then that baby found steroids. What ultimately lead me to the Westone ES5's was the realization that Westone uses vinyl tips for their custom IEM's leading to superior comfort than an all acrylic shell. I wanted something going that far into my ear to be of a soft material not hard.



 
Arrival of the Westone ES5's
 ​
 
     The Westone ES5 arrived to me via UPS. From the time spent sending my custom molds to Westone and receiving my Westone ES5, it took 2 weeks. The packaging of the Westone ES5 consist of a free T-shirt ( I wear it sometimes ) with Westone's logo and website labeled on it. There is a nice crush proof and water tight pelican case that in which you'll find your ES5's wrapped up nicely along with a microfiber cloth for cleaning the exterior shell of the IEM's. Also, there is wax removal brush, oto-ease bottle for easier insertion of the IEM's, and a desiccant pod which helps remove moister from inside the IEM's.
 
 
 
 
First impressions of the Westone ES5's
 
 
       Unfortunately, I wasn't able to listen to my Westone ES5's as soon as they arrived because I promised a friend that I would go with her to the Museum of Natural History. I thought it wouldn't be appropriate to take my Westone ES5's with me, because my attention wouldn't be on her or anything in the museum. As soon as I got home, I hurried to get everything that needed to be done, done. After reading on the web from many different areas I finally found out how to get the ES5's in my ears. For my first custom IEM it felt awkward I felt like I was underwater due to the superb noise isolation. Nothing else I've used isolated ambient external noise at this level. They felt nice and snug in my ears too. Within the first 2 minutes of the first song I played I couldn't help but chuckle and smile. The sound was just completely effortless, coherent, balanced, detailed and clear. I then sat there in my nice comfy chair and proceeded to listen to the rest of my musical library with my eyes closed and a big smile on my face.

 
 
 
The sound
 
 
        The midrange is no doubt the heart of the music and is a deal breaker for many in terms of the overall performance of a speaker. The midrange of the Westone ES5 are just slightly forward, but not ever congested. Male vocals are very natural and not overly chesty, or dry. The midrange has great body, but it does not have any noticeable coloration that I can hear. What amazes me the most about the midrange presentation of the Westone ES5 is how easily it lures you into the music and takes away what little grip you had with reality. It's very coherent and smooth. Great midrange simply produces a better connection to the music. The realism of the midrange creates great mental imagery corresponding to the actual instruments used to my ears. This type of categorizing happens subconsciously and is further an extension of the resolution of the Westone ES5. This helps me connect with the recording and enhances the musical experience. I expect much of the refinement in the midrange is suspect for this effect.

       The treble is extraordinarily clean. There is no grain, spit, grit, or veil of any kind here. The treble is very pure in nature, and it has no texture that detracts from transparency. In fact, I would classify the treble as being astonishingly transparent. Like the bass response of the Westone ES5, I sense no interference in the treble with any other parts in the frequency range. The marks in the treble seem to extend with realistic decay in all directions, which is remarkable for an IEM. The decay of treble is one best attributes of the Westone ES5. The resolution on the Westone ES5 help the decay in illustrating sound images accurately from beginning to disappearance. This strength helps in providing realism and building melodies. When a vocalist is harmonizing with other performers or instruments, the resolution of the Westone ES5 takes the music to another level. This effect is demonstrated nicely on Andre Reiu’s ‘The Flying Dutchman’.

      With its texture, extension, and decay, the Westone ES5's bass is something to appreciate from any audio enthusiast.  The quality of the bass is stupendous – very well defined, tight, and with great definition, extension and attack. The sub-bass in live recordings are retrieved with immediacy and accuracy on the Westone ES5. The Westone ES5's bass also scales up and gives you the extra distance if present in the source recording. Coming from a single subwoofer as opposed to the dual or quad subwoofers that the immediate competition utilizes I didn't expect this type of bass presentation. Boy was I wrong... For those on the fence thinking these are bass-light, lay those worries aside. But, they are not going to satisfy a bass-head unless some heavy EQing is applied.

     With the Westone ES5, it is easy, not “work”, to imagine real performers in real space. It’s very tempting to keep closing my eyes when listening to them, because the imaging is so convincing. For anyone who has avoided IEM's because they don’t image like headphones, spend some time with the Westone ES5. The stereo imaging on the Westone ES5's really shines with live studio recordings. With higher quality recordings, you can discern details such as when a singer moves his/her head while performing. This can be heard on Alison Krauss & Union Station's ‘Live’ during several passages. I have more easily noticed other micro details on the Westone ES5 such as singers licking their lips, fingers crossing over strings, or performers taking in a breath. Also, the decay of micro details and transients is nothing short of a strength on the Westone ES5.

 
 
Conclusion
 
 
      In short, the Westone ES5 is capable of producing a lucid yet vividly alive rendering of your best music. The Westone ES5's disappear completely. These monitors provide a plethora of details that come at the wearer with great accuracy and speed. The Westone ES5 has the ability to recreate music with realistic soundstaging, imaging and decay. There is a sense of realism in the Westone ES5's imaging, and where clarity and resolution are second to none. The Westone ES5 handles micro detail with the speed and attack necessary to image the effect's appearance, and makes disappear the effect with a natural sense of time. There is also very little to no roll off of the treble. I also detect no smearing of details nor marks anywhere in the imaging. Complex passages become alive with concise pace, rhythm, and timing. The Westone ES5 can provide accurate sound of varying volume levels that occur simultaneously in a recording.
 
     I would without a doubt recommend the Westone ES5 to anyone looking for a well balanced high-end custom IEM as I feel they are simply breathtaking. Thanks for reading my review and I hope you found it enjoyable!
kiteki
kiteki
Nice review I like the timeline history of your IEM's and thanks for reminding me I need to listen to more Alison Krauss.
Tronz
Tronz
Thanks a lot guys!
Dreamnine
Dreamnine
Nice review.
Back
Top