Strangelove424
500+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2012
- Posts
- 805
- Likes
- 221
I have been enjoying Grados and Beyers, but am tempted by all the forum talk about planar magnetics, and was curious about how my current DT880 would stack up against an in-my-budget HE-400...
It looks like all the fun parts of the frequency spectrum (and the sections typically described as "recessed" in my DT880s) went cliff-diving on the HE-400s. Okay, so scratch that, maybe I should move my budget up a little more to the HE-500s...
Seriously? I mean, seriously? According to this graph, they look like the exact same headphone. I would be surprised if two different sets of DT880s measured that closely.
Looking at the sine wave graphs, I don't really see the speed, precision, and fast decay attributed to planar magnetics either:
Looks like the DT880 actually has less resonance...
And the same, if not cleaner edges at 50Hz.
Distortion is better than Beyer on the low end, but as you can see a number of other phones are lower as well, so there's not anything special about planars here.
So am I missing something? Is there a special magic to planars that the measurements aren't capturing? I'm tempted to try them out, but nobody seems to be able to describe the planar sound in subjective terms clearly, and the graphs don't indicate that I'm missing out on much at all. If anyone has experience listening to both headphones, and can either confirm or contradict the graphs (even if using subjective albeit reasonably descriptive language) please chime in.
It looks like all the fun parts of the frequency spectrum (and the sections typically described as "recessed" in my DT880s) went cliff-diving on the HE-400s. Okay, so scratch that, maybe I should move my budget up a little more to the HE-500s...
Seriously? I mean, seriously? According to this graph, they look like the exact same headphone. I would be surprised if two different sets of DT880s measured that closely.
Looking at the sine wave graphs, I don't really see the speed, precision, and fast decay attributed to planar magnetics either:
Looks like the DT880 actually has less resonance...
And the same, if not cleaner edges at 50Hz.
Distortion is better than Beyer on the low end, but as you can see a number of other phones are lower as well, so there's not anything special about planars here.
So am I missing something? Is there a special magic to planars that the measurements aren't capturing? I'm tempted to try them out, but nobody seems to be able to describe the planar sound in subjective terms clearly, and the graphs don't indicate that I'm missing out on much at all. If anyone has experience listening to both headphones, and can either confirm or contradict the graphs (even if using subjective albeit reasonably descriptive language) please chime in.