I respect you Ethan, but in this case, I really can't agree that the Etys are for some select group of listeners that are some sort of fringe element. Of course, I don't feel that way about the IE8s either, even if they were not for me. Plenty of ER4P/S owners are people who love music, not a bunch of robots listening for tones and clicks. As far as being so far to one side of the spectrum, I can say I have both the DBAs, which I believe you really like, and the ER4P (but listening as the 4S via adapter), and on the same source, with the same amp, and the same tracks, and you'd be surprised at how close they really are. One thing is for certain, if the Etys are on an extreme end of the spectrum, the DBAs are sitting right next to them. I refer you the various ER4P/S threads on HF. I guess we disagree on what fun means, I don't believe it means coloration, for me, I find it fun (and other positive emotions too) to listen to a specific phone give me an amazing sound experience, a musical one, that is. Actual, real life fun, not some sort of sonic quality or steely cold objective. I have fun listening to both the Etys and the DBAs, and don't consider myself part of some outer fringe.
Are the Etys more accurate, detailed than most IEMs? Sure. But just like many, if not all, of the IEMs discussed here, variables such as tips, insertion, amps, sources, tracks, etc., can make the Etys sound better or worse. To say they only can sound a specific way, without taking those variables into account, is not a fair representation of them.
Of course they are not for everyone. I guess to me, that makes them special. As noted, I didn't really hear it the last time I owned them, but my upgraded gear, more flac files, etc., has changed my mind. You should keep yours open.
You say one can enjoy them, but fun is not "high up on the charts?" I would guess the folks at Ety would disagree. I guess I do after listening to them for the past day or so.
But why quibble? As I said, I respect you. It's just nice to be surprised by an IEM that I had written off, much like you have, as too extreme, when now, I find I was dead wrong. Now, let me go find those Etys, or should I listen to the DBAs? Nice problem to have.