Went to my local hi-fi shop yesterday evening to hear some headphones, and the Focal Elear was one of several that I checked out.
If sub-bass weren't a consideration, and if only considering mids & highs, then the Elears would be "tied in first place" with the Sony MDR-Z1R that I also listened to.
I was using my beloved Rockboxed iPod Classic, running through a Cayin C5 portable amp, and was playing the Chinese soft-rock song "Qin'ai De Ni Zai Nali" (“亲爱的你在哪里”)("Where are you, my love") by Long Fei & Men Li (龙飞 & 门丽). This song is on a good-sounding various-artist album that I bought on CD at a local store a few weeks ago, converted to MP3 at 192 kbps, and
added to my music collection.
You can hear this song (but with lackluster sound quality) at
this link. (I bought various-artist CDs at a local store, because most songs on Chinese web sites have lackluster -- or terrible -- sound quality.)
Anyway, with the Rockbox EQ and all bass boosts turned
off, the Focal Elears sounded slightly better than my beloved V-Moda M-100s (also without using any EQ or bass boosts) -- with slightly better clarity and detail.
However, when turning on the bass boosts in Rockbox and on the portable amp, and using the EQ preset "Ultra Lite Classic 3" in the "Cayin C5" set of
DiscoProJoe's Rockbox EQ Presets, the Focal Elear's drivers
bottomed out with the sub-bass and made a popping noise (and without
any clipping from the amp or EQ), so I quickly turned down the volume so it wouldn't damage the drivers.
(This song sounds best with my M-100s using that particular preset, and this combination totally blows away the competition, in my opinion, versus anything else.)
Anyway, I also tried this same song with the same sound settings with the Sony MDR-Z1R, and it sounded almost as good as my M-100s (and without the drivers bottoming out), but the Sony had slightly less sensitivity, and a little less sub-bass sensitivity, comparatively. But, of course, as with the Elear, the MDR-Z1R had slightly-better sound quality than my M-100s did with the EQ and bass boosts turned
off, and just as good of sound quality as the Elears.
Moral of the story:
If you don't use any EQs or bass boosts, and you don't care about price or portability, then get the Focal Elear.
If you
do use EQs and bass boosts (such as DiscoProJoe's Rockbox EQ Presets), if you don't care about price or portability, and are using a powerful
desktop headphone amp, then get the Sony MDR-Z1R.
However, if price and portability are big considerations for you, and especially if you're also using EQs and bass boosts (such as DPJ's Rockbox EQ Presets), and are possibly also using a
portable headphone amp to go with it, then the V-Moda M-100 is a no-brainer!
That's my story, at least.