Taikero
500+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2008
- Posts
- 983
- Likes
- 10
Quote:
Depends. I hear lead makes the water heavier and gives the taste some true weight. It's absolutely FANTASTIC.
Quote:
If one material is virtually frictionless in the pipe and the other material "grabs" water by its nature, maybe because it's a semi-porous material, the material is naturally "rough" (even at the molecular level) or is likely to rust or a number of other material-based variables.....
Additionally, you have to take into account the density of the pipe material, molecular structure, shielding, additional treating, when the material freezes/boils (freezing being the more important point), etc.
Back to cables, what about pure silver vs. silver-plated copper vs. straight copper? What about the difference between nickel-plated and gold-plated connectors (additionally, certain connectors are tipped with pure copper)? Can a reasonable person not at least admit the material makes a difference? If someone can believe that shielding makes a difference, why can't they believe that having less air/oxygen/whatever in the material/cable will help improve the cable's ability to do its job as a conductor? Less oxygen in the material is theoretically going to cut out signal loss by some amount by virtue of the material having more density. Perhaps the argument should be "Can you hear the difference?" rather than "Does it make a difference?", because it inarguably does make a difference (although depending on the differences and the measuring tests conducted, the measured difference may be very small. If so and a person hears a difference where a test says they shouldn't, perhaps the test isn't measuring for the right changes in the signal).
Regardless of price, it takes a level of pretty strong denial by anyone to think that the quality of the materials used to make a cable and the way the cable is put together to allow flexibility don't matter. Whether or not it makes a positive difference to the sound or not is a matter of debate, to be sure, but to say it makes no difference is really arrogant, IMO.
Originally Posted by Geruvah /img/forum/go_quote.gif No. I should've meant to say that with platinum, "will it make the water better by maybe making it softer or taste better?" |
Depends. I hear lead makes the water heavier and gives the taste some true weight. It's absolutely FANTASTIC.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CompressionalFlagellation /img/forum/go_quote.gif Well, if you want to go into specific detail of a simple example I made; lets assume the pipes are of exactly the same dimensions. I hope that you are not trying to correlate this to cables in that expensive ones transfer electricity faster than not so expensive ones? But hey, you're right; the thread went off topic, I pointed it out -- then joined in! Woohoo! |
Additionally, you have to take into account the density of the pipe material, molecular structure, shielding, additional treating, when the material freezes/boils (freezing being the more important point), etc.
Back to cables, what about pure silver vs. silver-plated copper vs. straight copper? What about the difference between nickel-plated and gold-plated connectors (additionally, certain connectors are tipped with pure copper)? Can a reasonable person not at least admit the material makes a difference? If someone can believe that shielding makes a difference, why can't they believe that having less air/oxygen/whatever in the material/cable will help improve the cable's ability to do its job as a conductor? Less oxygen in the material is theoretically going to cut out signal loss by some amount by virtue of the material having more density. Perhaps the argument should be "Can you hear the difference?" rather than "Does it make a difference?", because it inarguably does make a difference (although depending on the differences and the measuring tests conducted, the measured difference may be very small. If so and a person hears a difference where a test says they shouldn't, perhaps the test isn't measuring for the right changes in the signal).
Regardless of price, it takes a level of pretty strong denial by anyone to think that the quality of the materials used to make a cable and the way the cable is put together to allow flexibility don't matter. Whether or not it makes a positive difference to the sound or not is a matter of debate, to be sure, but to say it makes no difference is really arrogant, IMO.