Ok.
Just got these.
$400 shipped, used, only stipulation is that the stock cable is shorted. An aftermarket one has been provided as a substitute.
Bass immediately sounds offensive. Rolls off too early. Flabby and thick. Wait, why do these sound dark? Aren't these supposed to be bright? Turn them up a little. Holy ****, nothing could have prepared me for that treble. These sound super metallic. Gross, wow. Everything sounds wrong. Midrange is recessed. Upper midrange is almost absent. Treble is violent and sporadic. Ow.
Resolution is good, clarity is not due to recessed upper midrange. Soundstage is above average. Comfort is absolutely fantastic; almost better than HD800. Build is good. Frequency response appears to be the only massive issue with this headphone.
Bizarrely, these are the most tolerable with electronic music. I was expecting otherwise as most electronica is mixed poorly (brightly). The moment anything recorded comes into play, I want to gingerly rip them off of my skull.
More to come as I get used to them.
Congrats on your new HP's. This just goes to show you how different our ears hear things.
I find everything you said to be almost polar opposite of my experience with these cans. I will admit that the spike in treble was bothersome at first, but once they were burned in, they tamed down quite a bit (matter of fact, I find myself turning up the overall treble by +2 db). I can see where you might get the impression that the midrange is recessed, but when listening to songs with a big soundstage, those mids don't seem recessed anymore, but more like layered (and bigger than one might have thought previously). This is all coming from me listening through portable SS amp/dacs too... I haven't had the opportunity to purchase a good tube amp to make them even better... (thanks again for the suggestions DavidA>>>> going with the Ember).....
Is it possible they just need some burn-in time? Let us know how it goes....