aos
May one day solve the Mystery of the Whoosh
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2001
- Posts
- 1,841
- Likes
- 13
Quote:
Perhaps. When I was about 15-16 (half my current age) I listened to all Tchaikowsky that I could get to (wasn't too easy because where I lived at the time). I thought 4th Symphony was the best, 5th was good but not as good, and 6th was a good concept but not well executed - with the exception of the 3rd movement. I couldn't understand why the critics were considering it the best of the bunch. Well, understanding of other 3 movements came to me gradually over several years. Since then it became (and still is) the most important piece of music to me personally and the one I never get tired of (there were many days when I listened to it several times over and over). Though, the 3rd movement is still my favorite (and my all time favorite too).
But then it could be something else. Like some books have much more impact at certain time in your life, and later you can't seem to understand what was so great about them. Well, maybe that's not the right phrase, what I should've said is "what was that moved me so much when I had read them". I remember trying to re-read Hesse's Steppenwolf - which I identified with - several years later and couldn't get past more than a few pages. I don't think I could re-read War and Piece (which I also identified with) now either. Maybe the 6th isn't really better than 4th, it's just more appropriate for an older me.
Hating the Ninth just means you're going to become an addict later on. |
Perhaps. When I was about 15-16 (half my current age) I listened to all Tchaikowsky that I could get to (wasn't too easy because where I lived at the time). I thought 4th Symphony was the best, 5th was good but not as good, and 6th was a good concept but not well executed - with the exception of the 3rd movement. I couldn't understand why the critics were considering it the best of the bunch. Well, understanding of other 3 movements came to me gradually over several years. Since then it became (and still is) the most important piece of music to me personally and the one I never get tired of (there were many days when I listened to it several times over and over). Though, the 3rd movement is still my favorite (and my all time favorite too).
But then it could be something else. Like some books have much more impact at certain time in your life, and later you can't seem to understand what was so great about them. Well, maybe that's not the right phrase, what I should've said is "what was that moved me so much when I had read them". I remember trying to re-read Hesse's Steppenwolf - which I identified with - several years later and couldn't get past more than a few pages. I don't think I could re-read War and Piece (which I also identified with) now either. Maybe the 6th isn't really better than 4th, it's just more appropriate for an older me.