[icu222much]

I have a chance to get either a Turtle Beach DXL1 or Creative Fatal1ty headset for the same price ($35) and am unsure which one I should get. I see that normally the DXL1 is about twice the price of Fatal1ty, but I looked at the reviews for DXL1 and people are complaining about the flimsy construction and sound quality. I am unsure if they are basing this off a $100 product, or if the quality is really that poor.
My uses would be for PC. If I purchase the DXL1, I will also get the necessary adapters to make it work. My main use for my headset is gaming (mainly FPS) while talking with friends on Vent. My secondary use would be for watching movies. Comfort is not an issue for me as I have yet to find a non-comfy headset.
So, my question is which headset should I get and why. Turtle Beach DXL1 or the Creative Fatal1ty provided that they are the same price.

 

[DrSheep]

Get the TB or the ModMic 4.0, and read this:
 
http://www.head-fi.org/t/747043/unusual-headphone-problem

 

[no3no4]

Fatal1ty will be a better bet I believe, for your case

 

[icu222much]

  Get the TB or the ModMic 4.0, and read this:
 
http://www.head-fi.org/t/747043/unusual-headphone-problem

 
Why the DXL1? I read the link, but the information I got was that OP was storing the headphones in odd conditions as his TB also broke as well.
 
 
 

  Fatal1ty will be a better bet I believe, for your case
 

 
Why Fatal1ty?

 

[SonicScientist]

Haven't heard the Turtle Beach, but at least Fatal1ty sucks donkey balls. Hard to imagine that they'd be any better tho.