Quote:
Originally Posted by TrevorNetwork
Jatinder:
Why do you feel the Omega II's are "too flawed" to compare? I have heard the R10's, and the baby O (Admittedly not the big O), and I feel the Omega II's are quite superior to both. Please explain the "too flawed" statement.
Cheers!
Trevor
|
Hi Trevor,
I don't think I said that the Omega IIs are "too flawed to compare" - just that they were "too flawed" to my ears.
I had an Omega II/007t along with an R10/HP4 and an Orpheus. All three were completely standard and had been used well (ie. burned in).
When I first listened to the OmegaII/007t combo, I believed that it outclassed the R10/HP4 and the Orpheus - the Stax combo was just simply superb.
After listening to the Stax for several hours a day for several days with all kinds of music, I started to become irritated and annoyed by them. The problem was that there was just too much bass and there appeared to be a lack of treble resulting in an overall dark sound. I admit that I did not tweak anything in order to see if cables etc would fix it - feeling that my existing setup (speaker & headphone) didn't exhibit any darkness.
After that discovery, whenever I listened to the Stax, I would become increasingly irritated by the unnaturalness of the sound and this was happening sooner and sooner. It got to the point, that whenever I put them on, after a few minutes I would have to take them off and go to the Orpheus or R10.
Overall, the R10 & Orpheus were much easier to listen to. The Orpheus can be a little too revealing and sometimes is just a bit too bass shy with some recordings - but I can live with it. The R10 can be a bit bass shy sometimes too - and doesn't have the neutrality/transparency of the Orpheus - but again I can live with it. I couldn't live with the Stax because of the tonal imbalance that it presented - which for me, only became apparent after spending a fair amount of dedicated time with it. That's why I say it's too flawed.
I'd agree that the Stax (to my ears) was in many ways "superior" to the R10 and the Orpheus - hence why I instantly fell in love with it. However it is also in some ways "inferior" to the R10/Orpheus and the inferiorities far outweighed the superiorities - hence my quickie divorce from the Stax.
--Jatinder