[Jaman]

Initial reaction = lineup #1, but simply because of Master of Puppets, gotta go with #2.

**edit** and I am on the fence with black album, for me last REALLY good album was ...and Justice for All

 

[lmswjm]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaman /img/forum/go_quote.gif Initial reaction = lineup #1, but simply because of Master of Puppets, gotta go with #2. **edit** and I am on the fence with black album, for me last REALLY good album was ...and Justice for All

X2

 

[InFn-0]

KILL EM ALL

 

[lwells]

Really... Dave Mustaine?

He sucked in Metallica. I'm so glad he left/got booted. Now we have Megadeth.

 

[muddyglass]

dave is awesome. megadeth is awesome. nevertheless, the correct answer is: james, kirk, cliff and lars.

 

[lwells]

Quote:

Originally Posted by muddyglass /img/forum/go_quote.gif dave is awesome. megadeth is awesome. nevertheless, the correct answer is: james, kirk, cliff and lars.

Although I cannot deny I love to fall back to Kill 'em all every now and then.... Cliff was not there for And Justice. I do not think I could pick between Justice and Master of Puppets

That was all before 1990 though... unlike Metallica, Megadeth seems to still really rock.

 

[xtr3me]

Quote:

Originally Posted by muddyglass /img/forum/go_quote.gif dave is awesome. megadeth is awesome. nevertheless, the correct answer is: james, kirk, cliff and lars.

 

[Sherpa83]

James, Kirk, Cliff, Lars