Careful of Amir here, while I applaud his efforts to provide objective measurements and priority on ASR is typically given to science/fact rather than marketing, he has an agenda of his own regarding hi-res! We had a run-in with him here several years ago and he’s not beyond...

I think accuracy is a long way away, evaluation of exactly what information and scientific research is valid and applicable, and then weighing it all appropriately is seemingly well beyond ML currently. Not really, that is just the very first step and only of some science. If it is, then the...

This appears not only likely but extremely likely IMHO. It would explain why some/many of the sentences and sections in his posts are grammatically and syntactically correct while others indicate someone with a significantly poorer grasp of the English language. G

To be fair, there was some discussion about the difference between hi-res and oversampling much earlier in the thread but I don’t recall where. Ask pretty much any “audiophile” question and you get audiophile BS answers. I hope they sort out the learning model, etc. It would be interesting to...

We started from the position of either ignorance, “he hadn’t fully grasped the concept yet” or that he did grasp it but was deliberately trying to mislead others. Almost everything he’s posted since indicates the latter, falsehoods (including fake or misappropriated images)...

If that is the case (that it is not 1bit DSD) then it’s not necessarily inferior to PCM. In other words, it would be just as useless as hi-res PCM as a music distribution/playback format rather than even more useless! That it’s not particularly interesting, as it has nothing to do with...

But then you state this: Which is an obvious lie because I definitely did not acknowledge that, I acknowledged the opposite. I don’t think you could have come-up with a more obvious proof that you are lying (unless you actually explicitly admitted it). So thank you for as good a confirmation...

Just noticed these beauties! That’s because it didn’t, it just proved that 1bit DSD is not suitable for high quality audio applications. You know, the format you think is great but isn’t! That’s funny. Obviously it’s You “playing trick”! The ADC process requires a properly functioning...

No, thanks for yours, a perfect case of cherrypicking, confirmation bias and lack of critical thinking, unless of course you’re just lying? Thanks again, so you don’t know the difference. That’s a bit late, I stated the uses for hi-res right back near the beginning and now you’re thanking me...

In most cases yes but sunjam keeps going on about “absolutely” correct/perfect, only exactly 0% probability of being wrong is absolutely perfect and therefore he cannot accept 0.00002% as effectively correct/perfect in practice, IE. “Perfect but not absolutely perfect”. Unfortunately, he also...

No you are not correct, no surprise there! Don’t you think it’s absurd to be arguing in a sound science forum when you don’t even seem to know what sound science is? That’s where your critical thinking has led you is it? To answer your question, sound science is authentic but it is NOT a subject...

I have not seen any verified, reliable evidence that anyone can, even under 10 year olds. There is quite lot which indicates that adults can’t though. This paper by Nittono in 2020, “Moreover, the high-cut sounds examined in this study contained a temporal distortion (i.e. blurred onset and...

No, I didn’t, my apologies to @theveterans and @sunjam on this occasion, I wrongly misread the post below as from sunjam rather than to him. G

What do you mean “now”? G

So that’s a “No” then, you did not read the article you quoted before butchering it? That’s demonstrating critical thinking is it? If you had read it, you would have noticed that apart from the graphic you keep reposting, there are some other pretty pictures, some of which detect and quantify...

What are you talking about? You complain just a few posts about someone putting words in your mouth and here you are doing exactly the same. There’s a word for that! As I do not have “questions regarding ringing, oversampling, etc.”, how could those articles answer some of them? Duh! I have not...

Your question makes no sense. There’s no way to quantify (calculate) in advance the ringing artefacts with audio recordings but there’s obviously a way to quantify them when they happen, as you well know because you’ve repeatedly reposted the stair-step output graphic from an article that also...

Yes, you could indeed be wrong in interpreting someone’s message, especially as I shared “my viewpoint” in the sentences immediately after the one you quoted! lol So you have my viewpoint, or do you mean share the reason why 2012 might have some significance to your false assertions about...

That’s because it’s not live music! It’s a recording (IE. It’s been recorded and mixed/produced in a studio) and I would hope you can tell the difference, otherwise there would be no point in going to all the effort of mixing/producing/mastering recordings. The fact you or others can tell so...

Missed this: That’s debatable. Typically one does not consider cases where something is broken, for example, obviously a broken cable sounds different to a functioning one or a pig cannot fly better than fighter jet unless the jet is broken, etc. So it’s not really foolish not to consider a...

Yes, exactly. Not only is it cherrypicking information but it’s cherrypicking effectively invalid information because a filterless NOS DAC is effectively broken. Together with the “lies of omission”, he’s arrived at pretty much the exact opposite of the truth through an excellent example of...

And that encapsulates the problem with nearly all your posts and as far as I recall, all of your threads! Firstly, you do not present any theories, if you did, then it would be up to science to invalidate them. What you actually present is unsupported claims/assertions or vague ideas that you...

When people come here stating they can hear the difference between CD and Hi-Res the first thing we typically ask for is reliable evidence to verify their claim (such as an ABX) because scientific understanding indicates that no one should be able to hear the difference and the results of...

How long a person would wait in a Michelin 3-star restaurant for his main dish? How long a person would wait in a Michelin 3-star restaurant for his main dish, if he then applied a 30 sec filter to a sauce which evaporates and therefore doesn’t even exist when he eats his meal? Yummy, lol G...

So you get a good response to Dirac pulses which don’t exist in audio recordings! Who benefits from “not only don’t you “upgrade” anything, you pay for software not to upgrade anything and then have to wait 30 secs before you can hear the music.”? Yep, that’s what psychology training apparently...