Quote:
Originally Posted by blessingx
Is there a little inconsistency in posting "don't listen to anyone, trust yourself" expecting them to listen to your advice?
I mean that's why we're all here right - to give and solicited advice? Reviews are a part of that.
|
Yes and no.... Let me explain.
Generally I tend to shy away from "What do you think about XYZ headphone?"... kinds of discussions UNLESS a
common reference is stated. Personally, I'm much more likely to dive into details when the poster is requesting an A/B comparison.... or something of that sort, and a common reference sound is stated.
OK lets propose an example: Heres my comments on the SR125. Bright, aggressive, in your head soundstage. Good bass impact, marginal sub-bass extension, good treble extension....etc...
BUT is it all really that usefull without stating a reference point?
if someone asks me to compare the RA1 and HF1 for example, then I roll up my sleeves and dig into the details. I find that I am a much better reviewer when asked to make a, A/B comparison... versus general comments.
I LOVE reading A/B/C comparisons too. IMHO a comparison type of review is much more usefull than an "open ended" review. IMHO most www reviews are useless...." This headphone is bright and articulate"...
Compared to what? Compared to a portapro an HD580 is bright and articulate. Compared to an SR125 the HD580 is dark and less forward.
Anyways... thats how I see it.. Maybe others disagree and see it differently.
Garrett