helicopter34234
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2008
- Posts
- 153
- Likes
- 11
I really like it that the SA6 have detatchable cables and dissamble like they do. I am looking to get IEM in the $200 max range. Just wondering what people thought of them.
Originally Posted by schneller /img/forum/go_quote.gif How do the SA6s stack up against the UE Super.fi 5 Pros and Jays Q-Jays? I keep searching for the best $200 IEM, and I keep coming back to the Super.fi 5 Pros. They do get a lot of praise, but I wonder if they are rapidly become outdated by better competition. |
Originally Posted by maverick777 /img/forum/go_quote.gif I can't comment on the Q-Jays, but I do have the Super.fi's. The SA6 is better in almost every way except 2. The Super.fi's have more base quantity than the SA6's although not as clear. The SA6's reach just as deep if not deeper than the Super.fi's and have enough speed and quantity for trance for my taste but there just isn't as much of it. The Super.fi also have a different type of soundstage than the SA6's. With the SA6's you feel like you are inside the music. Like the music surrounds you. However, as other's have commented, the instrument separation could be a little better. With the Super.fi's, I feel the separation is better but not as clear. I feel like I'm on stage but not necessarily "in" the music. I think that has more to do with the "recessed" mids and good but not great highs. The SA6 is VERY well balanced across the spectrum. One instrument that goes missing with the Super.fi's are cymbals. It's the most noticeable difference to me so far. With the Super.fi's you hear the initial hit on the cymbals but then the sound just dies. With the SA6's, you hear them much more cleanly and you can hear the sound of the cymbals continue to echoe a bit in the background. Just as you would if you heard them live. The mids are MUCH better presented for vocals on the SA6. Lyrics are much more crisp and you can hear every little detail. Which may or may not be a good thing. Highs are also better on the SA6. You can hear all the instruments much more distinctly than the Super.fi's even though the separation seems narrower. Both are "fun" headphones. With the Super.fi's the emphasis is mostly on the bass with recessed mids and good highs. With the SA6's, there's a slight emphasis on the mids. Both sounding better than ER-4P's when you just want to relax and enjoy the music IMO. For me, there's no question the SA6's are better than the Super.fi's and ER-4P's. The are more comfortable than both of the other IEM's in terms of fit as well. As far as the Q-jays, from what I've read it seems like they have more bass than the SA6's but lose out a bit when it comes to the mids and highs. Both are great IEM's in this price range. The customization possible w/ the SA6's pursuaded me to buy them and I don't regret that decision at all. FYI (I'm used a SONY A829 with 192kbps+ mp3's with clear bass set to +2 and equalizer settings of 0,+1,0,+1,0 with the SA6's treble+/bass+ and Comply tips with the Super.fi's) |
Originally Posted by BloodSugar00 /img/forum/go_quote.gif Excellent conveyance of sleek's sonic character and frequency distribution! |
Originally Posted by schneller /img/forum/go_quote.gif maverick777: Thanks for the thorough review! I am looking at spending $200 on new IEMs and the SA6s are looking more tempting. |
Originally Posted by maverick777 /img/forum/go_quote.gif Thanks. That was my first review of the SA6's since I got them. The SA6's have been discussed thoroughly here so I didn't feel it was necessary for me to start my own thread about them. It was reading the SA6 thread that convinced me to buy them over the Q-Jays and UM2's. IEM's in this range are all "flawed" in some way. You just have to pick one that fits the music you listen to. The only way to have an IEM for EVERY type of music is to collect them all. |
Originally Posted by schneller /img/forum/go_quote.gif And what if female vocal trance is your type of music? |
Originally Posted by TheMarchingMule /img/forum/go_quote.gif I'm gonna be the wet towel here and say that of many IEMs I've tried over the years, only the Etymotic ER4S impressed me, and it was still a far shot away from a full-sized headphone. The SA6 was almost like the Vibes; warm mids and lows, tinny highs (with a bit of sparkle), and the percussion section was ruined. They sounded almost inverted, and basically off-pitch. It creeped me out, and yes I did try with all different tips and all different bass and treble ports. |
Originally Posted by TheMarchingMule /img/forum/go_quote.gif I'm gonna be the wet towel here and say that of many IEMs I've tried over the years, only the Etymotic ER4S impressed me, and it was still a far shot away from a full-sized headphone. The SA6 was almost like the Vibes; warm mids and lows, tinny highs (with a bit of sparkle), and the percussion section was ruined. They sounded almost inverted, and basically off-pitch. It creeped me out, and yes I did try with all different tips and all different bass and treble ports. |