Regarding DSD and the Loki chapter...
Quote:
<SNIP all that stuff before...>
So What About the Future
Okay. Let’s say the next Sony reorganization (they ain’t exactly healthy these days) doesn’t kill DSD, but results in them releasing 20,000 DSD recordings of popular artists, all with DSD-guaranteed-from-the-start provenance, for, say, $5.99 an album.
Would this result in a whole lot of DSD out there? You bet.
Would it be a game-changer? Absolutely.
Would it have us dusting off plans for a Loki 2, or working on ways to include DSD decoding in our DACs without compromise? Yeppers.
But I think that scenario is about as likely as the disembodied head of Steve Jobs giving the next Apple Keynote.
What’s more likely is this:
- DSD recordings will continue to be a small part of the market
- DSD recordings that actually start as DSD, or were converted direct to DSD from master tapes, will be an even tinier part of the market
- High-rate DSD with the same provenance will be even smaller
- DSD recordings will continue to be very expensive
- Some people will continue to really like DSD, and will flip us off as they pass us at shows
- More people won’t care, as long as the music sounds good and doesn’t cost a fortune
- Even more people won’t care if it’s DSD, PCM, or compressed, as long as it’s available to download at a good price
- And the vast majority of people will never have any idea what the hell us crazy audiophiles are talking about, as they happily stream compressed music for a small monthly fee (or free)
- About 10 years from now, a new quantum-based encoding format will come out so that everyone can buy their music again…
How about we deal with the elephant in the room, before worrying about formats, hmm?
So, I'll play the part of the gadfly here...there's one in every crowd, right?
I'm probably (as Jason remembered when I mentioned it to him at RMAF in 2013) one of the very first persons to get a Loki, or at least in Californina. IIRC, it was announced on a Monday or Tuesday or something like that, and I ordered it the day it was announced. IIRC, it was available for shipment immediately when it was first announced. I had it in my hands about two days later (I live in NorCal).
Turns out, I REALLY like, no love, my Loki. I think it sounds
fantastic. I think I wrote Jason an email the evening I got it, and basically mentioned that I was completely blown away about how good it sounded. For $149, it's performance was just ridiculously good. Yeah, I had to get a second USB cable for it, I picked up a used Audioquest Coffee for less than half price (great-sounding USB cable, and YES, they do make a difference), and also connected it to Gungnir with a set of interconnects.
Started buying content off Super Hi-Res at the same time. I can't speak to the provenance of the titles, but I was buying content that was orignally sold by Analogue Productions as SACDs, so my assumption was they started from a DSD recording.
While I don't have a lot of titles, the ones that I have dupes of, that is, 24/192 PCM vs DSD of the same title, I invariably prefer the DSD recordings. They sound more natural and analog-like.
That's on the whole, I have some really nice PCM titles (e.g. the newest HDTracks 24/192 Miles KOB) that are superb, so yes, the mastering of either format really does matter.
But at the end of the day, though,
I really like having the choice. And most times, If I've got a nice DSD recording, I prefer to listen to it rather than the PCM version. For example, the Shelby Lynne
Just A Little Lovin' DSD from Super Hi-Res is truly spectacular. Yeah, I have to press a switch and reset Audirvana, but it's not a problem....for the money it's a great solution for me, and I'm glad Schiit created that little trickster god of DSD, Loki.
Stephen Scharf aka Puma Cat.