So is Crucial CT480M500SSD3 480GB what I need for the 480 gig version? I plan to do a 480 gig model (possibly "just" the 256) as I just don't have that much music yet.
The Crucial 480GB is very good (also recommended by Beyondwind) with a good battery (e.g., the Miliamp 650 mAh). I loaded it completely full just thru the USB without a single issue. The BP4 240gb is excellent choice and requires no special battery. The Samsung 1TB will give you plenty of storage but also trouble if you intend to load it just thru USB. Also I suspect a power failure during playback may bring an unhappy face to the ipod.
What I think I need :-
Ipod (preferably 5th gen, but with tarkans adapter any model will do basically). I do have a 7th gen ipod but am leaving that alone as don't want to be without music.
480 gig Msata
Tarkan/generic adapter for msata
2000mah battery (optional)
Anything else?
Other concerns.
1) Being a Mac Mini user will I have any trouble transferring files across once the build is done via usb? I am aware that it is best to do it in small chunks at a time (10 gig or so) due to heat issues.
2)Being a Mac Mini user if I do run in to trouble and need to reformat the ssd what's the best way of going about it? Would an external msata case to usb be any good?
3)Rockbox, with rockbox do I do the install before or after the ssd mod? It's this part that has me slightly confused. I'm guessing after.
To install RB, you restore the ipod first. Then you enable the diskmode, from there you install the generic RB firmware followed by the RB patch by beyondwind.
Being honest I'm leaning more toward ordering a 256 gig compact flash komputerbay card atm and seeing if that works in the mini. I'm aware that msata cards are cheaper but there seems to be more pitfalls to avoid that way as well. Only reason I have not done that yet is because a)I'm tight and b)when I tried the 128 card from komputerbay it was quite unstable to say the least.
CF mod is no doubt the best, in my opinion, if you don't need a big storage. I also have the Komputerbay 128GB CF for my 5g, and my experience is different from yours. In fact, all my CF mods are very very stable free of any issue. CF's are the most reliable and power efficient.
Here are the CF cards I have used:
Wellcore 256GB
Komputerbay 128GB
Dolgix 128GB
Maxell 64 GB
Promaster 64GB
Any thoughts on the above?