Quote:
Originally Posted by Audio-Fi /img/forum/go_quote.gif
You shouldn't compare Nintendo DS to PSP. Everything DS does PSP does way more. It plays PS1 and old Nintendo classics for free if you mod it which is relatively easy. As far as being media player, it is one of the best especially the 16:9 ratio screen. I haven't spend a lot of time with DS to judge the battery but PSP has plenty enough so you can watch three 2 hour movie back to back. Hell you can get all whatever PSP plays for free but I don't support that. Just be sure to bring extra battery pack with you.
|
If we are strictly talking about something to keep him entertained, which is what the thread specified, I personally consider the DS to be a valid option over the PSP. Especially If we are strictly speaking in terms of a gaming machine not a PMP.
I own 2 psp's, (a 1st generation and a slim), as well as a DS lite and I have to say that the DS has a much better game catalog and better support from third party developers. As far as
real PSP games go there aren't very many that are even worth their 40 dollar price tag.
On the positive side the PSP has mp3 playback, and a great screen for watching movies as well as mod-ability which easily can counter the lack of real games If you don't mind playing old ROMs that in my experience don't always run as smoothely as the original cartridges or even a good PC EMU. And PSONE emulation is no where near the level it should be.
When it comes to battery life the DS easily trumps the PSP in this area as well. But I think that's to be expected considering the fact that the PSP's LCD screen is so much larger and power consuming then the DS's screens. As well as the fact that the DS runs on Carts and the PSP runs on UMD's which require more power to read from. Also I've noticed that the PSP can be annoying when loading from a disc, it produces a grating sound. Nothing too major, but significant enough to receive a mention.
Summary:
If you are basing this purchase off of available retail games, and battery life the DS easily wins. I would also say the DS lite beats the PSP on portability.
And backwards compatibility with Gameboy Advance titles is a nice touch as well broadening the game catalog further.
The PSP however is the clear winner on additional features. Somewhat poor battery life can be be fixed with a spare battery(at additional cost of course)
Don't expect as wide a catalog of retail games though.
Also if you do get a PSP definitely invest in either a case or a screen protector because its a real scratch/finger print magnet.
Good luck