First of all Pharmaboy, thanks for actively posting and finding different clones and versions of the isk mdh9000, I have been closely following your posts and this thread for a month now.
I'm sort of a little dilemma and need some recommendation here; I'm looking for a set of closed back headphones that I can listen to music when traveling, at home and occasionally at work (but we have a pair of on-ear Plantronics bluetooth headsets), I listen to a variety of genres (pop, techno/trance, basically anything that has some beats, but mainly pop), I do care about isolation but I am more keen on comfort and sound. I don't like too much bass. And if it matters, removable cables would be nice but not a deal breaker, like I said I care more for sound and comfort than the extra features. So far I have found these as my options:
- Status Audio CB-1
- Audio Technica M40x (I was planning to get m50x for a while, but because they are bass and muddy, I'm not interested in them. A lot of people prefer the m40x over the m50s anyways)
- AKG K553 Pro
- Sony MDR-7506 (have previously owned a pair but it's been a while so I honestly can't remember the sound signature, all I know is they were very comfy and portable - minus the coiled cables lol)
Sorry my budget is Canadian $100-120. So far I'm leaning more towards the Status CB-1s since the audio (as other reviewers and Pharmaboy also spoke highly about them), they are foldable, so portable and most of all since they are super comfortable.
Massdrop has a promo on the AKG K553 Pros for $120 and then shipping, but I've been thinking, if I go for the m40x or the AKGs I'll be looking to change out the pads which may or may not change the sound quality and the CB1s already come with great angled pads and are comfortable so the value here is unbeatable. Amazon has the CB1s for $90 and I'm a prime member so free shipping. M40x are about $150 in Canada, if we get a sale maybe they go towards $110-120 and then looking at the pads, overall cost increases, same with the AKGs so technically the CB-1s are clear winners.
I have also looked at others mentioned here, like the Marantz or LyxPro or Yenona as well, but converting them to CAD from USD and the amount of time it gets to get em from AliExpress or another Chinese vendor (to Canada... ) I'ts better to just buy the CB-1s. Only con I see here for the Status audios are the build quality, plastic but like Pharmaboy said not in a bad way, but both AKG and Audio Technicas are built way better.
Anyone has any other suggestions that I mentioned, please let em know
edit: forgot to mention, I'll be driving them with my LG G5 smartphone, a PC at home with good on-board audio (laptop at work) and maybe an ipod classic
Well, I have the Yenona's & Marantz MPH-2's and CB-1's; and owned a pair of AKG 553's (though I've never heard any AT headphones). So I can speak to at least some of your concerns.
First, the AKG 553's. These are physically the largest of these 4 headphones, particularly the earcups, which seem larger in diameter than any of the others to me. I can't remember if the cable was detachable or not. The AKG's were my first headphone, and I never was able to like them. Without EQ, they sounded bright and bass-shy to me. EQ helped, but it still wasn't good enough. Now, to be fair, I got all my current HP amps except 1 (FiiO E10K) after selling the AKG's, so it's possible they'd sound better on my more recent, higher quality amps.
The Yenona's are very light and comfortable, probably pretty good for portable use. The cable is detachable & easily upgraded. But...they might be too bassy for you.
The Marantz MPH-2's (which sound identical to other ISK-MDH9000 clones, incl. the LyxPro HAS-30's, which I had, then gave as a gift)--are moderate in weight, not especially heavy; probably relatively portable. They have a detachable cable. This my favorite inexpensive closed back HP at the moment--but again, you might find them a little bassy. I personally do not find them to have notably elevated bass. I really like the quality/impact of the bass, not just quantity of it, and find it is completely in balance w/the mids & treble. Great headphones, really.
As for the CB-1's, I have them F.S. only because they are so close to the Marantz' in sound quality that, once I burned them in and auditioned them thoroughly, it made little sense to hang onto them at a time when my headphone headcount was getting out of control. They sound very good, are rather light/portable, and have a detachable cable. And despite what some reviewers said, I find them to be relatively good looking. These should be good for portable use.
As for build quality, the AKGs are built somewhat more strongly than the others, but if anything, their comfort is a little less: there isn't much padding on inside of headband; and the those wide circular earcups have relatively shallow pads, so your ears may touch the drivers. And unlike all the other headphones mentioned here, you can't easily upgrade the earpads should you feel like doing that. Of the others, I think the Marantz' are quite sturdy, and the Yenona's & CB-1's slightly less so. But really, they're all pretty fine IMO. I really don't see notable weak point in the construction of any of these headphones. If you use them with just a little common sense (no slamming them into things; don't stretch the headband violently in direction opposite to its curve; etc), they should be fine.
All things considered, the CB-1's probably are the best choice for you.