So I had some time when I was definitely not procrastinating about packing to A/B the sony str-6120 and the mac-1900. I gave them both a few minutes to warm up, then I listened to the FM radio back to back through each receiver. I tend to agree with your impressions, the 6120 is ruler flat and very good across the entire range and is my reference amp while the 1980 and 800c are out for a refurb. The mac was "mellow" and "laid back", which I think are words that indicate somewhat higher, but not annoying, distortion and noise levels. It's important to say that it really wasn't annoying to listen to: it was smooth enough to listen to for hours without going crazy.
I felt like there was more distance between me and the music, and it wasn't as detailed as the sony. I flipped back and forth mid-phrase to catch the same passage on both amps. The highs are somewhat muted on the mac, maybe indicating a lower rolloff frequency on the 1900, possibly around 20-ishkHz for the -3dB point. It was able to bring them back forward with about 2dB of treble adjustment to a fairly flat response, but that also brought up the noise floor a tad with it.
I took another pass at the 1900 through the phono 1 input, playing a few songs off of "History of Eric Clapton", try and get a better sense of how the amplifier section sounds. I'm fairly pleased with it. It was very nice quality; silkier, with less noise. There was still a decent amount of rolloff, which makes me continue to think the amp has a -3dB point around 20kHz. The phono section was much less noisy than the tuner and basically made the entire amp for me. It was easy to listen to and detailed enough to satisfy me. The same songs on the sony had a cooler character with clearer highs, but it was good listening on both for sure.
I found the mids to be fairly warm. If you have very bright, analytic speakers/headphones, then this might be a good amp to tame them.
Looking under the hood, this amp is 100% McIntosh based on build quality. I think there must be some servicing that will bring the noise down and clean up the sound. Since it is largely card based, I think this amp would be relatively easy for a DIY'er to work on and/or modify.