Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphones, Earphones and In-Ear Monitors › [REVIEW]: The Aurisonics AS-2 15mm Dynamic Driver 2-Balanced Armature Hybrid Custom-Fit Stage Monitor
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

[REVIEW]: The Aurisonics AS-2 15mm Dynamic Driver 2-Balanced Armature Hybrid Custom-Fit Stage...

post #1 of 96
Thread Starter 

Synopsis: The Aurisonics AS-2 is a high-end custom-fit in-ear stage monitor with a lively, rich sound. It has a unique, crossover-free design that allows its 15mm dynamic driver and two special balanced armatures to work together seamlessly. With an adjustable bass port system, the AS-2 provides a real bass energy in just the amount you want. Combined with a lush midrange and an accurate, non-fatiguing treble to balance it, the AS-2’s focus on an organic, live feel to music will make it a hit with both musicians on stage and music lovers at home.


 

 

 

Introduction: Aurisonics entered the high-end professional stage and portable audio scene with a bang. Innovative designs (the very first of which was nominated for a TEC award last year), continual evolution and an openness to input from pro musicians and audiophiles alike, have made it a company to watch. In particular, many of us have been watching for the AS-2, Aurisonics’ flagship earphone. With the AS-2 custom-fit in-ear monitor (ciem) and the universal-fit ASG-2 rolling out, I knew I had to hear the best Aurisonics has to offer.

 

 

 

Aurisonics and its founder: Dale Lott may have just recently founded Aurisonics, but he has a long history in professional audio. With experience making high-end audio designs for military, aerospace (!) and professional sports applications as well as stage designs for professional musicians, Dale is way more than your typical audio engineer. He offered his expertise to some of the popular high-end audio companies and when they let the opportunity slip through their fingers, he opened up their his own company. Boy, are they going to be sorry! He’s bringing his experience to his in-ear monitor designs and the results are very interesting.

 

Before we start looking at the AS-2, there are some things that you need to know:

 

 

 

Custom Fitting: For a custom fit in-ear monitor, first you need to get the right fit. The process, as many of you know, involves going to an audiologist to make a set of impressions of your unique ears. Getting a perfect fit with a custom monitor is the key to getting the best sound, the best comfort and the best isolation. Your fit will be only as good as your set of impressions, so it’s very important to work with an audiologist who has experience specifically taking ear impressions for pro musicians’ stage monitors. Do not cheap out here, you will pay for it later! You deserve the best and it will save a lot of trouble. My advice is that the audiologist should use a 1” bite block—this holds open your mouth as the impressions are made. This is necessary because as you open your jaw to sing (or yawn, I suppose, it’s your music), the shape of your ear canal changes. Try to relax your jaw as much as possible during the process as that effects the ear canal as well.  Because each set of ears is unique, keep in mind that it’s a process that has the potential for an imperfect fit, either for sound or comfort. If that’s the case, contact the manufacturer (Dale, in this case) immediately. Don’t come here to whine, I can only offer sarcastic comments, whereas Dale will actually help you. That leads me to the next topic:

 

 

 

Customer Service:  Because we’re dealing with custom-fit design and no one has ears quite like yours, customer service is a huge consideration with ciems. It’s very, very important. Many companies have dropped the ball here, some catastrophically, some just by being run by people who don’t get customer service. Fortunately, Dale is a completely stand-up guy and Aurisonics has already shown itself to have excellent customer service in the year and half it’s been around. While there are always, and I do mean always, issues that will come up, Dale has your back and he will work with you and he will take care of you. What more can I say? Let's go to the AS-2:

 

 

 

The AS-2:

We’ll start with the price: It’s $800 and it competes with ciems that run hundreds of dollars more.

Buy them here

 

The AS-2 I'm reviewing is a review sample.

 

 

Design: The AS-2 is innovative in a number of ways. This starts with the drivers that actually produce the sound. Typically, customs use balanced armatures in multiple sets and have crossovers to divide which part of the music is produced by each armature. This often leads to a particular, artificially separated sort of sound. The TWFK family of dual armatures used for treble or midrange and treble in many ciems also has a slightly artificial sound due to a spike in its sound signature at around 5khz. Bass is as much felt as heard and armatures in a sealed earpiece also do not to produce the air-moving quality that allows us to have a sensation of feeling this real bass energy.

 

Dale overcame these issues one by one: First, by using a large 15mm dynamic driver that’s more like a miniature speaker for real bass. There is an adjustable bass port so each person can dial in the amount of bass they want. Next, for added treble performance, he combined this driver with two new, special armatures which have a more natural sound than the TWFK armatures. Finally, the way he combined these two driver types is also unique as he did it in a crossover free design, giving the AS-2 an organic soundstage that gives a much more live music feel.

 

He didn't stop there:

 

For better fit and comfort, the part of the AS-2 that goes into your ear canals has a special coating over the acrylic.

 

The socket where the removable cable meets the earpiece is one of the most likely places to fail on a ciem. Dale has a special reinforced semi-recessed socket design for greater reliability.

 

The faceplate has a unique design for reliability and easy servicing.

 

There are some patents pending on all this!

 

Take a look at my poorly-taken pictures (really, they do not do the AS-2 justice):

 

 

 

I have the black, stealth faceplates. For your AS-2 you can choose a different look entirely if you like.

 

 

 

 

The big round 15mm dynamic driver is easily seen.

You can just make out the two special armatures below it.

 

 

 

 

 

My ear is for display purposes only and does not come with the AS-2.

 

 

 

 

Isolation:  Isolation is the amount of outside noise blocked out by the earphone. Some people will want less isolation so they can be aware of the outside world for safety and other reasons (being aware when people are trying to talk to you, etc.). Many people will want more isolation because then they can focus on their music and at lower volumes. The AS-2 has moderate isolation with the vents open which can become quite good if you close the vents. With the vents open, there is wind noise, so if you go outside, you may want to close the vents which will eliminate it.

 

 

 

The Sound: I used the lovely Apex Glacier DAC/amp to drive my AS-2 for this review with high quality sound files on my beloved ol’ 5.5th gen ipod.

Note that the AS-2 is absurdly easy to drive. There always seem to be people who want high-end ciems but don’t want to use an amp that has the power to drive them properly. This is like buying a Ferrari and then putting cheap low-octane gas and flabby little tires on it. The AS-2 is perfect for people like this as it sounds great even out of an ipod. It’ll sound a bit better with a small portable amp, of which the Apex Glacier is one of several examples, but it’s quite easy to drive. For getting the very best performance, particularly with healthy, lower volume listening, consider an amp for your high-end custom in-ear monitor and better tires and gas for your Ferrari… 

 

 

 

Overall: The AS-2 excels at conveying the experience of being in a room where live music is playing. The overall focus is definitely on the total sound coming together in the room and rocking you. There is good detail there and excellent imaging in a very nice soundstage that lets you know where every musician is the room, but this is secondary. This is a very dynamic driver style sound—even though it’s a hybrid with special balanced armatures along for the show (and it is a show with the AS-2), the no-crossover design leads to a very organic, very coherent sound. If this is what you are looking for, you’ve found it with the AS-2.

 

This is a stage monitor by design and tuning and that means a few things you should know when considering the AS-2: You should expect a slight lift in the vocal range to bring male and female singers just a little forward and bring music alive. Although everyone has their preferences (and some recordings will sounding better with a given tuning), I find this small lift in the tuning makes a big difference for an enjoyable listening experience. Without it, an initially great sounding earphone will start to lose its luster for me over time.

 

The second thing you’ll often hear in a stage monitor is a non-fatiguing treble. A non-fatiguing treble should still be able to sparkle, but it should also avoid spikes in the frequency response that lead to sibilance or a screechy sound. This stage monitor sound is just how the AS-2’s treble is tuned. That doesn’t mean you won’t hear overly bright or harsh high-pitched sounds in your music, just that the AS-2 won’t be contributing to that harshness coming from your recording or player/amp. Keep in mind, some people actually prefer a raspy or piercing treble as these can give the illusion of added clarity (as the listener goes deaf…). You won’t find that here, for which I’m thankful!

 

The final thing that a stage monitor will often have, but not always, is a bit of extra bass for drummers and bass players. The adjustable bass in the AS-2 goes way past 11, so it’s got this angle covered. I’d recommend keeping the bass vent mostly closed as just a little opening is all most people will need. Bassheads, however, (you know who you are) will be very happy letting the big 15mm dynamic driver breathe.

 

 

 

Treble: The AS-2 has a lovely, smooth, accurate treble. As I mentioned, it’s non-fatiguing, and doesn’t add any sibilance harshness or glare to what’s there in the recording or added by your player/amp. I tried out a few recordings I know that are particularly bright and the AS-2 gives you that brightness with a bit of the piercing glare polished down for you. I like the accuracy combined with a smooth sound. It’s very nice for long listening sessions and the AS-2 lends itself to losing yourself in the music. 

 

Perhaps it’s the special armatures used but the treble has great timbre for a ciem—the life-like reproduction of subtle resonances in voice and instrument that rings true to the listener’s ear. It’s simply superior to balanced armature based custom iems using the popular TWFK family of dual-armatures (which is many of them). Cymbal crashes sound great and natural, for example. The AS-2’s treble manages to give a detailed sound subsumed within the lush sound that the AS-2 seems to naturally flood the ear with due to the big 15mm dynamic driver. We’re not looking at an analytic or cold treble here, but one that brings immediacy and presence to your music. It isn’t recessed but nicely balances the power of the midrange and bass. Female voices sing out clearly in the rich mix of sound.

 

 

 

Midrange: These mids are rich, warm and they really bring music alive. While the AS-2 can easily keep up with fast music, it adds a thick, full, powerful sound to guitars, bass and strings. Male voices are resonant and clear as well. Other earphones may end up sounding dry and a little dull to you after you experience the AS-2.  Interestingly, I found the bass vent also gives a little added flavor to the mids. You can open up the adjustable bass vent more for an extra helping of this resonance in the lower registers or keep the bass vent only open a small amount for just a little added juice to the lower midrange which is quite nice.

 

 

 

Bass: The AS-2 gives you what bass sounds like. Real bass is felt as much as heard and for that you need a vented shell design for your earphone so air can move. I’ve heard audio engineers talk about how air movement with a vent shell earphone is important for ear drum and listening fatigue as well, but I can’t speak to that except to say I think the AS-2 lets you experience it for yourself. The AS-2 is qualitatively different from the typical closed shell balanced armature ciems out there in terms of bass. You are getting something that even the most bassy balanced armature earphone lacks. If you want that, you’ve come to the right place. If you don’t, well, you can close the bass vent entirely and…you’ve still come to the right place! The vent system means you can really choose what you want and you can go from a very polite bass all the way to bass that powerfully booms.

 

There is truly exceptional, superior sub-bass extension with the AS-2. The mid-bass is plentiful. I love bass and I needed to dial the AS-2’s adjustable vent down to just a little open. Dale himself told me he keeps his around ¼ of the way open—and that’s still a very good amount of bass! At that level, it's nicely controlled and has a great heft to it. If you go more than that...well you'll get more!

 

Just to be clear: If you close the bass vent entirely, you get very polite bass which is still present but stands a little behind the midrange—perfect for people who don’t want a bassy earphone. So, the AS-2 with the vent system is quite a versatile earphone.

 

 

 

Conclusion:  The AS-2 is a professional stage monitor with a very lively, organic sound where each part of the music comes together and rocks. There is great bass energy, rich mids and treble that sings while never shouting. Although the detail is all there for you, the AS-2 is for living the music, not picking it apart. Music just seems to flood your ear at every volume with the AS-2 and you can’t help but be moved. It’s an excellent ciem for those who are looking for the sound it so richly provides and I think it will be very popular both on stage and at home.


Edited by Kunlun - 11/17/13 at 10:55am
post #2 of 96
Thread Starter 

The comparison with the Heir Audio 8.A is here!

 

Coming Soon!

 

Comparisons with the Tralucent 1plus2 and with the Future Sonics MG6Pro

 

 

 

Aurisonics AS-2 versus Hier Audio 8.A

 

The 8.A is an 8-armature 4-way crossover custom iem that retails for $1300 ($500 more than the AS-2).


For a complete description of the 8.A’s sound, you can look here. In brief, the 8.A has a strong bass and a rich midrange sound with relaxed, non-fatiguing and smooth treble. While some feel the treble is recessed, it fits within the overall sound of the 8.A which gives a warm sound without sacrificing clarity. Let’s look how the AS-2 compares to it.

 

Overall, there are two important differences, the first is simply that the AS-2 uses an adjustable vent in the shell with a dynamic driver supported by two special armatures in a crossover free design while the 8.a uses a more typical closed shell with multiple armatures and crossovers.

 

The second is in the tuning. The AS-2 is a stage monitor as I’ve described in the review, with a lift in the vocal range.

 

Let’s start with the bass. The 8.A has great bass for an armature earphone. It’s very well controlled by a special acoustic filter and there is sub-bass extension and power. Some will find it too bassy and while it is bassy, the control means that the bass tends to fit the recording well. The AS-2 also has great sub-bass and mid-bass. The AS-2’s adjustable bass lends it a musical flexibility, taking the bass from politely behind the midrange to a nice powerful presence all the way up to a full power that almost no other earphone can match. The vented design of the AS-2 means that there is air movement which no closed shell ciem can have. We feel bass as much as hear it and the AS-2 has a real bass energy that the 8.A simply doesn’t. Some people will find that they like armature bass. Without the bass energy, an armature’s bass can sound more controlled. However, the lack of live-sounding bass energy also contributes strongly to the way an armature ciem sounds like it’s playing a recording. The AS-2’s bass sounds more real and alive by comparison. I like live music, so that’s important to me, but you will have to decide for yourself.

 

Midrange. As warm as the 8.A can sound, the AS-2 can be even a bit warmer. With the bass vent more open, the lower midrange takes an added warmth. With the vent more on the closed side, the extra warmth reduces and you have simply a nice warm midrange. You can see how I like the AS-2 on the more closed side, but you may feel differently. The midranges are actually not so very different between the two earphones in giving slightly different takes on the same warm approach. The AS-2 can be slightly richer with its big dynamic driver, the 8.A sounds slightly drier.

 

The treble presentations of each ciem have some interesting differences. They are both non-fatiguing, not too bright or harsh. However, there’s a key difference in the tuning. The 8.A has a bit of a dip in the lower treble while the AS-2, as a stage monitor, brings this range out a bit. The result is that the AS-2 brings the vocal and lead instrumental part of a group forward and music generally sounds more alive. While I am always stunned by the 8.A initially, over time I find the lack presence in this range dulls the experience. The AS-2 strikes a better balance as it remains a lively listen even after a long time yet doesn’t fatigue the ears. Keep in mind that it’s all a trade-off. So the 8.A can sound clearer in this range with more sense of space to parse each note. While the AS-2 will sound more forward and alive. The crossover-free design of the AS-2 leads to a more blended sound where the detail (which is still there) is secondary to the overall organic presentation and the 8.A, which is still nicely coherent for a multi-armature design, sounds more laid back, more separated and distant in the soundstage.

 

That leads me to the soundstage. They are about the same overall, but the 8.A, as noted, sounds more open in the treble, while the AS-2 is more precise in imaging in this range even as it brings the vocalist closer to you.

 

For timbre, the AS-2 has better timbre in the treble by avoiding the TWFK family of armatures which the 8.A has. Cymbals sound better and more real. As I mentioned, when the AS-2’s vent is more fully open you can get added warmth in the lower midrange, so I would go with a more closed vent for the best timbre with something like piano music.

 

The isolation will be better on the 8.A if you have the vents open on the AS-2, otherwise they are the same.

 

Reliability is a  key difference. With 8 armatures, 4 crossovers, etc., there’s a lot packed into the 8.A and what has to give is the thickness of the acrylic shell. The AS-2 has a thicker acrylic shell and the cable socket has a much sturdier design. While the AS-2 is new on the market, the design of the build is stronger than the more typical 8.A. Naturally, you should treat your high-end ciems like the treasures that they are.

 

In conclusion, they are both excellent, top-tier earphones with great bass, warm mids and non-fatiguing treble. I often recommend the 8.A to people, even though I don’t listen to it very much myself. This is because I think it’s a great balance for a person who likes the clarity and presentation of armature ciems but wants something relatively warmer with bass capability and a non-fatiguing smooth treble. The 8.A will sound clearer with a more matte sort of feel to the sound compared to the AS-2. Though well detailed, the AS-2 will sound a lot livelier, more like live music than a recording. It’s a much more involving sound that, in direct comparison, makes the 8.A sound a little dull. The AS-2’s bass has real energy and the treble is not recessed. The adjustable bass vent gives added flexibility to the AS-2’s sound. It has a more sturdy build. And it’s $500 less. Which one is right for you, though, is up to you.


Edited by Kunlun - 5/5/13 at 1:53pm
post #3 of 96
Thread Starter 

I'd like to invite owners of the custom-fit AS-2 with adjustable bass vent to post their impressions in this thread.


Edited by Kunlun - 4/30/13 at 7:48pm
post #4 of 96

Great review, this CIEM has always interested me, sadly I don't have the funds to make it look as cool as I want it :P

post #5 of 96
Thread Starter 

It looks very cool just in the base shell. I can tell you for a fact that my old AS-1 got more compliments and several from very pretty girls than any of my other customs (with wood faceplates, etc.).

 

So, trust me, you'll be getting something that attracts the right kind of attention. Plus, it's the music that counts!

post #6 of 96

After the current pair I'm ordering, I would consider these on build quality alone. The ASG-1's I owned felt indestructible, and I'm sure the customs are even more durable!

post #7 of 96
Quote:
Originally Posted by mosshorn View Post

Great review, this CIEM has always interested me, sadly I don't have the funds to make it look as cool as I want it :P
" Oh nice, gold facepla... 500 DOLLARS ?!?!?!?! "
post #8 of 96

Thanks for the review Kunlun!

 

Quick and dirty question- if you were stranded on an island with only one CIEM, which one would it be?

post #9 of 96

Thanks for the review.  I'm eager to read your comparisons.  A few questions:

 

If you've heard the AS-1 how big a leap in sound quality is the AS-2 comparatively?

 

Does the special coating mentioned make a difference in comfort or seal?

post #10 of 96
Quote:
Originally Posted by -xX-Mew-Xx- View Post


" Oh nice, gold facepla... 500 DOLLARS ?!?!?!?! "

They really should change it to "solid gold" faceplates. 

 

It'll make sales fly~

 

Of course it definitely wouldn't end in the company going bankrupt...

 

 

Though I do wish that polished came standard. (I know about their different production method)


Edited by EveTan - 4/28/13 at 9:56pm
post #11 of 96
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChrisSC View Post

Thanks for the review Kunlun!

 

Quick and dirty question- if you were stranded on an island with only one CIEM, which one would it be?

You're welcome!

 

Answer:

 

I would ditch all of them and bring one of those emergency radio/GPS homing things.

 

Sand and salt water are bad for ciems.

 

The truth is that personal preferences are very subjective. I try always to write a review that describes the earphone in a way lets you figure out if it's right for you.

 

The CIEM makers tend to be unhappy with this because "I LOVE IT SO MUCH I WANT TO MARRY IT*" type of review seems better in the short run, but one like mine helps people to buy something they will truly be happy with and in the long run I think that's much better.

 

I'll tell you a story because I like to tell stories:

I got a private message from a person who was unhappy with their top-tier ciem. He knew it had the wrong sound signature for him, but he bought it because people said it was just so awesome that he figured he'd like it anyway. And he was wrong! There's a moral in there somewhere...

 

 

 

 

 

 

*no offense, only love to my Hawaiian homie

post #12 of 96
Thanks for the review Kunlun. I eagerly await details concerning the upgrade program now smily_headphones1.gif
post #13 of 96
I love the way they look in your ear tongue.gif
post #14 of 96
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deviltooth View Post

Thanks for the review.  I'm eager to read your comparisons.  A few questions:

 

If you've heard the AS-1 how big a leap in sound quality is the AS-2 comparatively?

 

Does the special coating mentioned make a difference in comfort or seal?


It's a definite leap if you want those special armatures to give you more treble over what the AS-1 has. I think the AS-1 is super non-fatiguing while the treble of the AS-2 is more balanced, detailed and present while still having a non-fatiguing quality. So, the sound signature is slightly different and some people might want to stay with the AS-1, but the AS-2 is a step up and the upgrade option is very cool.

 

 

Yes, the special coating is a definite help with both comfort and seal.

post #15 of 96

Thanks Kunlun- agree with your answer, even if it is politically correct biggrin.gif.

 

Reviews tend to have a lot of weight, and its probably not a great thing to endorse one thing as best cuz like you said, there's enough FOTM talk going around, and no need to contribute.  My bad for putting it into the public forum.

 

do me a favor, and send me a quick PM stating which one would be YOUR preference (strictly subjective) cuz we've got pretty similar sonic preferences and I'm curious about how much I'll like these (I'm expecting a lot- I got a pair, but have to get them refit).

 

Thanks bud

 

ps: I wonder if a certain someone will be divorcing his tralucents biggrin.gif

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Headphones, Earphones and In-Ear Monitors › [REVIEW]: The Aurisonics AS-2 15mm Dynamic Driver 2-Balanced Armature Hybrid Custom-Fit Stage Monitor