Intro
I first saw Pump Audio on Kickstarter, "The greatest headphone in the world?" and "Better than Beats" lay across the banner. One bold statement, and one not so bold. All jokes aside, I sent the owner of the Kickstarter campaign a private message, and he provided me with a free pair for review. The following opinion is my own and, as always, your mileage may vary. I have had the headphones for a few months and have spent a lot of time with them. This review will be beefy and cover all bases. There will be a summary at the end for those who want to save some time.
Packaging
Who cares, right? It seems that was Pump Audio's approach anyway. It's not bad. Thin, printed cardboard encases thin plastic that surrounded everything in a clamshell fashion. In this case everything means three pairs of tips (two sizes only), and the IEMs themselves. Nothing to write home to your mom about, but Pump Audio asks $150 for these, I expected something better. Will this story of mixed expectations continue?
Build
The build to me is nothing spectacular. Maybe it's the designer in me that sees the whole thing as a disconnected mess. The orange is a different color on the shell and the cord, and it doesn't look purposeful. The strain relief has slits cut at the connector, but not by the housing. Those housings themselves are nice enough. Anodized aluminum which is light and looks pretty, however there is an unsightly seam right in the middle of the unit that runs around it. Pump could have (and should have) aligned this seam with the silver colored accent ring, in order to better camouflage it. Or they could have aligned it along the edge where it narrows to the nozzle.
Let me take some time out to talk about how bad this cable is. This cable is the same cable that was on the free pair of in-ears that I received with my HTC One M7. Not similar, but identical in everything except color. It is flat, so points for that, but it is cheap. It is a touch thicker than a business card and has the same rubber used on phone cases. This thing creases and grabs onto everything it touches and tangles poorly despite being flat. I would have liked to see the cable be a bit thicker, not as wide, and not have so much friction on the outside. Cable noise in subpar too.
Fit
The light housing does wonders for the fit. The flat cable all but necessitates straight down wear, but as long as you're not running and you can call these Tom Cruise. They'll never come out!
Oddly enough, the housing where the silicone tip latches on is smaller than normal. It uses standard tip sizes, but the housing just isn't large enough for the tip to grip housing. The tip won't fall off, but it does rotate freely. Thus, when it is in the ear, the earphones will spin when leaning your head in any direction. This left me with an odd sensation and a squeaky fart noise in my ear, every single time I moved my head. Shame.
Sound
Bass
Oh my bass! Good bass! Heck, great bass! And gobs of that tight awesomeness! The only thing I can compare it to is the Sony MDR-Z7 which I hear has nearly identical bass to the Fostex TH-900. It is loud, it slams, it goes deep, the mid-bass isn't inflated at all. It starts to dip around 15 Hz but the rest of it is still there all the way down to 5 Hz. This is the best bass that I've heard on an in-ear headphone. It bests my Sennheiser IE7, it beats my Ostry KC06, it wipes the floor with my Zero Audio Carbo Tenore. It sounded better in the bass department than the Fidue A73 and A83 that Hisoundfi let me demo at ChiUniFi this year. The bass sits roughly 2 dB less than what you get from the Beats by Dre line, but that doesn't mean they are wooly. There is just a lot of bass. If I had to find one gripe about the bass it would be that in complex passages you hear that it isn't notably fast. That said, I'd still say it has the best bass among any IEM under $200 that I've heard.
That is, of course, unless they don't seal. In which case you are left with an airy, tinny, thin mess. The housing issue I mentioned earlier makes this a very common problem with almost all aftermarket tips. So you are stuck with the S or M/L basic tips that they offer. Thank goodness they are decent.
Mids
Nothing special here. At all.
Treble
This is where the Pump's fall very far. I know what you're thinking. Don't think it. This is not another hip-hop only headphone with such little treble that Meghan Trainor is throwing herself a party. It is present, it sparkles, it is detailed. Not Beyerdynamic sparkly and not HD800 detailed, but pleasing and present nonetheless. These tied my Ostry KC06 in the detail department and those things are no slouch. I'd say the treble presentation is very similar to my Ostry KC06, but I much, much prefer the Ostry's for treble alone. They both are right where I'd say neutral is, maybe touch less around 4kHz to reduce fatigue. But the Pump's are a peaky mess. It took me a while to figure out why one guitar note was so much louder than another. And why every once in a why Taylor Swift's voice would gain and lose it's sparkle from word to word. I've come to the conclusion that there are multiple resonances and anti-resonances within the housing that result in this awkwardness. It isn't colored or unbalanced here, it is just wrong. It is something that you could miss, but when you notice it (and you will), and you will hate it as much as I do. Which is a lot. I hate it a lot.
Soundstage
Average for a good earbud. Some width, no height, little depth.
Isolation
Awful.
Conclusion Time
So basically Pump Audio made a killer driver with a ton of awesome bass and nice highs and mids too (in that order). Then they hacked together a housing and cable with little regard for basic sound principles and/or for the laws of design. Then they slapped a price tag on it and it simply cannot compete with anything near it's price range given the bad design, cheap feel, and messed up treble. I see these in-ears pop up on deals sites quite a bit and they sell for about $100 on there. Still not worth it.
Basically it's a prototype. A darn good prototype, but it is not ready for mass market. It cannot compete with in the already oversaturated IEM market and it needs to be revisited and revised. It won't be hard. Make it look like a finished product, add a better cable, dampen the inside of the housing and you've got a fantastic IEM. And I mean that sincerely. This could be the kingpin of basshead IEMs, but it isn't. Every time I use them I think the same thing. If they spent another 1-3 months on this, this prototype could be a killer IEM. But they didn't. And it isn't. Do not buy this, I'd recommend Beats before these because at least the newer ones are well built.
Edit: They broke. After months of gentle use they worked fine. I gave them to my brother, who used them over his Beats Urbeats (if that says anything). He says he pulled them out of his pocket and they were broken, right at the Y-split. No drops, no yanks, nothing. I don't doubt it. The housing just slid together, that means any tension was put directly onto the soldered joints.
I first saw Pump Audio on Kickstarter, "The greatest headphone in the world?" and "Better than Beats" lay across the banner. One bold statement, and one not so bold. All jokes aside, I sent the owner of the Kickstarter campaign a private message, and he provided me with a free pair for review. The following opinion is my own and, as always, your mileage may vary. I have had the headphones for a few months and have spent a lot of time with them. This review will be beefy and cover all bases. There will be a summary at the end for those who want to save some time.
Packaging
Who cares, right? It seems that was Pump Audio's approach anyway. It's not bad. Thin, printed cardboard encases thin plastic that surrounded everything in a clamshell fashion. In this case everything means three pairs of tips (two sizes only), and the IEMs themselves. Nothing to write home to your mom about, but Pump Audio asks $150 for these, I expected something better. Will this story of mixed expectations continue?
Build
The build to me is nothing spectacular. Maybe it's the designer in me that sees the whole thing as a disconnected mess. The orange is a different color on the shell and the cord, and it doesn't look purposeful. The strain relief has slits cut at the connector, but not by the housing. Those housings themselves are nice enough. Anodized aluminum which is light and looks pretty, however there is an unsightly seam right in the middle of the unit that runs around it. Pump could have (and should have) aligned this seam with the silver colored accent ring, in order to better camouflage it. Or they could have aligned it along the edge where it narrows to the nozzle.
Let me take some time out to talk about how bad this cable is. This cable is the same cable that was on the free pair of in-ears that I received with my HTC One M7. Not similar, but identical in everything except color. It is flat, so points for that, but it is cheap. It is a touch thicker than a business card and has the same rubber used on phone cases. This thing creases and grabs onto everything it touches and tangles poorly despite being flat. I would have liked to see the cable be a bit thicker, not as wide, and not have so much friction on the outside. Cable noise in subpar too.
Fit
The light housing does wonders for the fit. The flat cable all but necessitates straight down wear, but as long as you're not running and you can call these Tom Cruise. They'll never come out!
Oddly enough, the housing where the silicone tip latches on is smaller than normal. It uses standard tip sizes, but the housing just isn't large enough for the tip to grip housing. The tip won't fall off, but it does rotate freely. Thus, when it is in the ear, the earphones will spin when leaning your head in any direction. This left me with an odd sensation and a squeaky fart noise in my ear, every single time I moved my head. Shame.
Sound
Bass
Oh my bass! Good bass! Heck, great bass! And gobs of that tight awesomeness! The only thing I can compare it to is the Sony MDR-Z7 which I hear has nearly identical bass to the Fostex TH-900. It is loud, it slams, it goes deep, the mid-bass isn't inflated at all. It starts to dip around 15 Hz but the rest of it is still there all the way down to 5 Hz. This is the best bass that I've heard on an in-ear headphone. It bests my Sennheiser IE7, it beats my Ostry KC06, it wipes the floor with my Zero Audio Carbo Tenore. It sounded better in the bass department than the Fidue A73 and A83 that Hisoundfi let me demo at ChiUniFi this year. The bass sits roughly 2 dB less than what you get from the Beats by Dre line, but that doesn't mean they are wooly. There is just a lot of bass. If I had to find one gripe about the bass it would be that in complex passages you hear that it isn't notably fast. That said, I'd still say it has the best bass among any IEM under $200 that I've heard.
That is, of course, unless they don't seal. In which case you are left with an airy, tinny, thin mess. The housing issue I mentioned earlier makes this a very common problem with almost all aftermarket tips. So you are stuck with the S or M/L basic tips that they offer. Thank goodness they are decent.
Mids
Nothing special here. At all.
Treble
This is where the Pump's fall very far. I know what you're thinking. Don't think it. This is not another hip-hop only headphone with such little treble that Meghan Trainor is throwing herself a party. It is present, it sparkles, it is detailed. Not Beyerdynamic sparkly and not HD800 detailed, but pleasing and present nonetheless. These tied my Ostry KC06 in the detail department and those things are no slouch. I'd say the treble presentation is very similar to my Ostry KC06, but I much, much prefer the Ostry's for treble alone. They both are right where I'd say neutral is, maybe touch less around 4kHz to reduce fatigue. But the Pump's are a peaky mess. It took me a while to figure out why one guitar note was so much louder than another. And why every once in a why Taylor Swift's voice would gain and lose it's sparkle from word to word. I've come to the conclusion that there are multiple resonances and anti-resonances within the housing that result in this awkwardness. It isn't colored or unbalanced here, it is just wrong. It is something that you could miss, but when you notice it (and you will), and you will hate it as much as I do. Which is a lot. I hate it a lot.
Soundstage
Average for a good earbud. Some width, no height, little depth.
Isolation
Awful.
Conclusion Time
So basically Pump Audio made a killer driver with a ton of awesome bass and nice highs and mids too (in that order). Then they hacked together a housing and cable with little regard for basic sound principles and/or for the laws of design. Then they slapped a price tag on it and it simply cannot compete with anything near it's price range given the bad design, cheap feel, and messed up treble. I see these in-ears pop up on deals sites quite a bit and they sell for about $100 on there. Still not worth it.
Basically it's a prototype. A darn good prototype, but it is not ready for mass market. It cannot compete with in the already oversaturated IEM market and it needs to be revisited and revised. It won't be hard. Make it look like a finished product, add a better cable, dampen the inside of the housing and you've got a fantastic IEM. And I mean that sincerely. This could be the kingpin of basshead IEMs, but it isn't. Every time I use them I think the same thing. If they spent another 1-3 months on this, this prototype could be a killer IEM. But they didn't. And it isn't. Do not buy this, I'd recommend Beats before these because at least the newer ones are well built.
Edit: They broke. After months of gentle use they worked fine. I gave them to my brother, who used them over his Beats Urbeats (if that says anything). He says he pulled them out of his pocket and they were broken, right at the Y-split. No drops, no yanks, nothing. I don't doubt it. The housing just slid together, that means any tension was put directly onto the soldered joints.