Head-Fi.org › Head Gear › Headphones › In-Ear › Universal Fit › AKG K3003 › Reviews › k3oxkjo's Review

About as good as it gets for universal IEM's

A Review On: AKG K3003

AKG K3003

Rated # 64 in Universal Fit
See all 9 reviews
Review Details:
Audio Quality
Comfort
Design
Isolation
Value
k3oxkjo
Posted · 6107 Views · 11 Comments

Pros:

The AKG K-3003 is at least close to a landmark Universal IEM, in my view. Pricey, yes, but one of the first Universals to aspire to the heights that the best of the Custon IEM's aspire to. They are well built (though some may not like the idea of non-detachable cables) and attractive enough. But the real issue is, of course, the sound, so let's get right to it.

 

The first thing that hit me about the AKG's is that they invite comparison to full size phones in certain ways more that other IEM's. The combination of excellent coherency top to bottom, excellent but not hyped detail and resolution, low distortion, good dynamics and relative neutrality show up even good IEM's such as the Sony MDR-EX1000, Audio Technica CK-10, Ortofon EQ-7 and the like as pretenders. Let's take some of these features forward for further scrutiny.

 

Coherency 

 

These sound quite consistant as a solo instrument (piano, violin, guitar etc.) is played up and down the key/fret board. Lesser IEM's will tend to, worse case, sound uneven in amplitude or, less destructively, thin or fatten the harmonic envelope (this is where our ability to discern instruments of different model/construction comes from) under these conditions. A good example of this is the album The Virtuoso Guitar as played by Alirio Diaz on a Vangard recording. If the guitar doesn't sound like the same guitar through its range, the illusion of an expert musician playing his instrument is damaged. This coherency pays off even further during the Castelnuevo-Tedesco Guitar Concerto #1 off this album where the interplay between soloist and orchestra is preserved.

 

Detail

 

The high linearity (low distortion) of the 3003 allows one to hear deep into the lower levels of recordings without the masking effects of distortion products. This allows low level information to be heard in the mix of popular music or orchestral presentation. This allows things like the "humming along" Ivan Moravec provides in his VAI label Beethoven recordings (original on Connoisseur Society) or the various sonic manipulations on the Beatles "Strawberry Fields" to be heard clearly for what they are. This detail is not the "thrown in your face" detail of certain treble emphasized phones but is an organic part of the recording not obscured by transducer playback artifacts.

 

Dynamics

 

This is where the 3003 really excells over lesser IEM's. The combination of lack of low level artifacts and high (for IEM's) level linearity makes for a wide dynamic envelope. The Fritz Reiner RCA recording of "Isle of the Dead" (off "The Reiner Sound" album) is a great example of this. This recording starts very much hushed (as befits a piece called Isle of the Dead) but swells to quite loud crescendos. The AKG's can accomodate this without distortion (beyond the slight tape saturation on the highest peaks endemic to the otherwise excellent late '50 recording) or without compromising the soundfield by coagulating the instruments together, quite a feat for an IEM. Careful, don't listen too loud! The low distortion and high levels attainable can lead to this...

 

Relative Neutrality

 

I use this term because I am not sure what absolute neutrality would be. Neutral to the recording? Neutral to the original sound of the original performace? Neutral to some preconsceived idea how a phone "should" measure? Neutral to the your personal preference? Or some combination?

 

The AKG tends to be neutral to the recording, which tends to result in a somewhat front-of-the-hall perspective. Still neutral to the original performace, but some may like a bit of a more distant perspective as personal preference. One of my tests for the "gestalt" of the concert hall is the EMI recording of the Barbirolli Mahler 9 with the Berliner Philharmoniker. This is a good, but somewhat forward, recording of an excellent performance of this evocative piece. If the playback puts you into the hall without putting the forwardness "over the top", it's good playback. The 3003 does this, to be sure.

 

For further evaluation, let's go to the classics. I personally use Iggy and the Stooges "Search and Destroy". This is a recording made with the VU meters pegged, as it should be! An IEM that can deliver the swagger, threat and excitement of this is doing it justice and the AKG does it justice, in my view. A particular favorite group of mine is the sound world of The Legendary Pink Dots. The combination of the Silverman's swirling keyboards and Edward Ka-Spel's wispy lyrics and vocals (inside joke) make for music that can take you to some less-visited places inside. The fact that I can be sitting on the train on the way home from work and still escape to the Dots' world is as good a recommendation as I can give.

 

Bottom line. Between AKG, Final Audio Design and various of the custom designers the IEM has been brought into higher levels of performance than ever before. Here in the States, one has to give credit to Ultimate Ears and JH Audio for pioneering the idea that custom IEM's can aspire to greatness and that audiophiles would respond to the performance by paying the price. And now we can thank AKG and Final Audio Design for believing that those of us who don't want customs would also pay for high performance.

 

Some will balk at the 5 star rating for value. The K3003 are indeed not cheap, but I know of no way currently to get equivalent performance in a universal IEM at a lesser price. To me, that's priceless.

 

11 Comments:

-balks at the 5-star rating for value-
I appreciate the discussion of coherency and anyone who listens to Barbirolli's Mahler 9 has a good ear for music. Good review.
Great Review. What custom IEMs have you heard so far?
I love how people are basically focusing on the five star rating for value while ignoring the rest of the review.
Thank you for discussing coherency and dynamics. So many reviews simply boil down to "bass is like this, treble is like this, mids are like this" and don't discuss any other facet of how something sounds. You seem to have a good ear for this, so I appreciate your sharing. Can't wait to give these a listen myself.
I'm all for good sound, but those are over-priced. Great review, regardless, but I don't agree on the rating for value. IEM's are incredibly cheap to make. I think Harman is trying to take a bite of the high end audio pie.
"The K3003 are indeed not cheap, but I know of no way currently to get equivalent performance in a universal IEM at a lesser price."
Is that because the Bill of Materials is so expensive or because the company charges what they think the consumers will bear?
temporaryname, the cost of R&D is a significant contribution to the cost of any product. Harman is a top company that hires engineers with expensive and hard earned degrees. How much do you think their salary is?
I agree that their profit margin may be large, but until there there is a product that competes with the k3003's performance at a lower price point (crosses fingers for vsonic's GR08), one can't really say anything solid about the price.
The part about R&D is true, but still, when you compare the price to the equivalent in technology, a camera, motorbike, laptop, TV, PlayStation3...
Harmon is a company that bought out many smaller companies who hired engineers with expensive and hard earned degrees. Over time, many of these geniuses have left these sub-divisions of Harmon. They have since been replaced with very good marketing people. I know a few of these ex-Harmon engineers and I believe they fondly refer to Harmon Kardon as Harmon Kardboard. This is just another point of view which is neither right or wrong nor true or false. Not too different from the Star Trek Episode: A Matter of Perspective: http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/A_Matter_of_Perspective_%28episode%29
I understand that the price is high. However, it is competition that drives prices down, and at the moment there is none. If the $320 Vsonic GR08 that has a similar driver configuration ends up with similar or better sound than the K3003, Harmon will be presented with the ultimatum to either lower their prices, or simply not make sales. It's what happened with Nvidia vs ATI, and other similar examples.
Oh this is a great review, I agree, but honestly, once you surpass the ~$500 zone you are so far past the point of diminishing returns that you're pretty much just getting either sidegrades or like a .01% increase in sound quality...I agree that things can sound wonderful and excellent at this range, but I just don't feel that anything really truly deserves a 5/5 on value unless, say, they absolutely blow away every other custom IEM in the same price range.
I just like everything about the review but the value rating; I feel that is a little bit excessive, but I can of course still respect his opinion.
Great review! Personal, easy to read and understand, very entertaining, and lots of examples of music. Thanks!
Head-Fi.org › Head Gear › Headphones › In-Ear › Universal Fit › AKG K3003 › Reviews › k3oxkjo's Review