bigshot
Headphoneus Supremus
Controlled listening tests are all that really matter when it comes to home audio.
Controlled listening tests are all that really matter when it comes to home audio.
Could you please move that discussion to one of the appropriate gear-porn threads ?
Trust me, you really don't want to post a 'amp-review' in the 'Sound-science'-thread -
Unless you have measurements to show ..
gear-porn
it's not the size of the tube, but oh boy are they slick.
I'm actually very much for a comparison of low disto SS vs low distortion tube amp. if some people could do it it would be great.
but to be meaningful in any way we would need "a real one". by that I mean to know the actual distortion values when listening on that given system, some matter of blind test, volume matching, make sure that the impedance differences wouldn't modify the headphone FR. and that would be only basic requirements, not an easy task at all.
else how do we know that we're talking about the sound of the tubes and not just some FR trick, some amp instability, some damping problems, one being louder, or just one being pretty?
I'm actually very much for a comparison of low disto SS vs low distortion tube amp. if some people could do it it would be great.
If the distortion on both is beneath the threshold of audibility, and the response on both was flat, I don't see what there would be to talk about.
The best tube amps sound as good as solid state.
not at all, I talked about that only because I'm concerned that what the manufacturer gives us might be different than reality.
if the given values stand for the reviewer's gears, then I totally don't care about inaudible distortion levels. don't mistake my past comment for some 0.00001% THD fetish ^_^.
inaudible is good enough for me.
If the distortion on both is beneath the threshold of audibility, and the response on both was flat, I don't see what there would be to talk about.
The best tube amps sound as good as solid state.
Considering the fuss that some folks make regarding whether or not their kilobuck amp has superior tube sound AND some perfectly transparent capability unachievable by a modestly priced but equally spec'd solid state amp, I would say that there would be quite a bit to talk about. Mostly we would talk about how there really shouldn't be anything to talk about.
Sometimes it is necessary to fight back against the constant stream of gibberish spewed in anti-reason forums with some common sense discussion.
Cheers
Bruce Coppola did that, but the results weren't what the site hosting his review wanted to hear, so they deleted it.