First of all a big thanks to
@Kamakahah for setting this up and my apologies for not posting my impressions sooner – life and all that.
As time permitted, I spent about 90 minutes straight with each cable, listening to various genres. Music files were MP3, FLAC, WAV, PCM and DSD. I then started switching cables. I tried to be systematic about it, keeping the swaps to 6 per selected track, sometimes listening to the complete song, others just a snippet. All of my “serious” comparisons were against the stock cable, with casual swapping between the OFC, SPC and V-Moda cables later on. Setups used included an Asus laptop with either an HRT microSTREAMER or NuForce uDAC-3, Asus Windows tablet with the same and an Oppo BDP-103 through the headphone out of a T+A Power Plant.
The biggest difference, though still slight, was the SPC vs stock cable. On some tracks (not all, mind you) there was a bit more shimmer and sparkle in the highs. I could not detect a significant difference in the midrange or bass. Three tracks that really stood out to me were “Dead Already” from the
American Beauty soundtrack, the title track from Ani DiFranco’s
Up Up Up Up Up Up (both CD) and “The Ubiquitous Mr. Lovegrove” from the Dead Can Dance SACD
Into the Labyrinth. These songs feature very well recorded and dynamic L/C/R percussion. With the SPC cable, aside from the aforementioned highs, the presentation took on a more holographic image with increased width, depth and
height. I compared the two over and over because I was suspicious of what I heard (I am a bit of a cable pessimist) but it was there and it was very cool! I am sure if I delved deeper into my music collection, I could find more examples, but time did not permit.
Comparing the OFC and stock cable produced negligible, if any, results. The same goes for the cable from V-Moda.
When I purchased the X1s, I bought the V-Moda cable because that is what I thought I was
supposed to do due to everything I read on this and other sites whilst researching. It was not quite a waste of money because I like the V-Moda cable better than the ones that came with my M-100s (it is longer and more pliant). It was only though careful and studious listening that I heard a difference between the SPC and stock cable. If I were to have the SPC on hand and plugged it in one day, I would not in any way be overwhelmed with “night and day” differences and/or improvements – I would simply sit down and enjoy myself. All in all, this was a very enjoyable experience, but this is not how I listen: I listen for the sheer pleasure that music brings, not gear. Yes, I want the best reproduction that my budget allows, but obsessing over kit is something I got over a long time ago.
Conclusions: (1) the “Philips Fidelio X1 Stock Cable Debacle” is way overblown (2) the supplied OFC and SPC cable were quite well made, really nice looking - especially the
blue - and the connectors were very, very secure and tight; I started to worry that the jack into the X1 would fail because, well, I read somewhere that it could happen – I guess I have not learned my lesson and (3) the X1s are supremely fine headphones just the way they are – but I already knew that!