Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Computer Audio › Deezer vs Spotify - bitrate / sound quality
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Deezer vs Spotify - bitrate / sound quality

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 

Both services claim "up to 320kbps" bitrate, yet some people say they hear a difference in sound quality between the two and insist Deezer sounds better than Spotify. Is anyone able to confirm this? Has anyone done any extensive A/B comparisons? If so, can you point me to the songs where you hear the difference? The difference is obvious to me between normal and high quality streaming or, say, Rdio and Deezer/Spotify HQ, but Spotify and Deezer in high quality mode sound exactly the same.

 

I'm just curious about this. If the difference is as apparent as some people say it is, I should be able to hear it. So is it me or is it yet another case of people hearing something that isn't there?

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 9
Hi fufula I did a comparison last night and Deezer is miles better than Spotify ..Sound wise spotify is smoother and can sound more impressive than Deezer but I feel Deexer is much more musical ie you can follow the interplay of the musicians better , Prat is superior, diction is better, music sounds more exciting and alive. The only thing going for spotify is its more stable. Although I think having spotify loaded affects Deezer ..that could be chrome ..ill be comparing browsers today.Even comparing Deezer through my Note 2 pissed over spotify which has a higher bit rate ..this is through 10GBP skullcandy earphones(which are amazing!!!)and aktiv Linn Klouts
post #3 of 9
Thread Starter 

Hi there,

were you using a dedicated app on your Note 2? If so, what's the bitrate in it? It's only 128kbps in the Windows Phone app vs 96/160kbps (the latter is optional) in the Spotify app.

 

As for desktop, are you talking about web players or were you using the Spotify desktop client? If so, did you enable high quality streaming and disable normalization and hardware acceleration?

 

There's also WiMP and MOG that offer 320kbps streaming if you want to test even more stuff.


Edited by fufula - 11/3/13 at 5:15am
post #4 of 9
Hi Fufula its the dedicated app on phone ..its only 120 odd kbps but I don't hold too much credence with bit rate ..I have an mp3 player that sound better than a wav player and all iPhones..I judge it more how the player renders the file; compressed or not. Linn DS klimax playing mp3 sounds close to magik DS playing flacs..spotify was maxed out ..always thought it sounded really dull ..thanks for the heads up
post #5 of 9
Thread Starter 

To me, even between 160kbps and 128kbps the difference is easily discernible, with the former sounding better. Deeper soundstage, more space between instruments, punchier bass and the highs aren't as garbled. Then again, it's hardware and OS dependent. Not to mention the sound coming out of my phone ain't nothing to write home about, and that's putting it lightly.

 

I did some more tests with the desktop players, as that's what I'm mostly interested in.

 

I measured the amount of data downloaded per song for at least 20 different songs on both, Deezer and Spotify. It turns out that with the high quality streaming enabled Spotify always streams 320kbps files. Deezer, on the other hand, seems to stream a lot of files at only 128kbps even though I always kept HQ enabled. What's interesting is that despite the differences in bitrate, I couldn't easily tell which service sounded better. So it makes me wonder, does the music I used for the tests sound equally bad in 128kbps and 320kbps or do both companies get 128kbps encoded material from the labels but only Spotify reencodes it at 320kbps (which would be kinda stupid)?

 

Does anybody use these services? If so, it'd be nice if you guys could chime in on this. I'm going to try and compare some music that I own physically with the streamed stuff some time later this week.

 

My setup:

Essence ST > DT990PROs

Samsung Omnia M > MH1Cs, KSC75s


Edited by fufula - 11/12/13 at 5:22pm
post #6 of 9
I hear you fulula .that's good to know but for me Deezer at 128 sounds better than spotify at 320 much more musical ..I know some Naim heads who buy CDs from Naim and rip them to the same high quality mp3 that can be downloaded from Naim site and they can't get their mp3s to sound good as Naims ..which do you prefer D or S!?
post #7 of 9
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by fufula View Post
 

What's interesting is that despite the differences in bitrate, I couldn't easily tell which service sounded better. So it makes me wonder, does the music I used for the tests sound equally bad in 128kbps and 320kbps or do both companies get 128kbps encoded material from the labels but only Spotify reencodes it at 320kbps (which would be kinda stupid)?

 

I did a lot more A/B testing with Deezer HQ/Spotify HQ (and / foobar FLAC for good measure) using well recorded music. Spotify always came out on top when Deezer streamed at 128kbps (even though it was set to HQ streaming the entire time) and it wasn't really discernible when it streamed at 320. So, to answer my own question, it was the former.

 

It seems Deezer encodes the less popular stuff at 128kbps hoping people won't notice to preserve bandwidth. So the "up to 320kbps" statement on their website basically translates to: it's either 320kbps or 128kbps. And if you happen to be listening to less known stuff like I do, you'll be getting most of your music at crappy 128kbps. My recommendation is to stay away from this particular music streaming service until their get their act together and start serving all of their collection at an acceptable bitrate.

post #8 of 9
Hmm not so sure about that F..let peoples judge for themselves ..spotify sounds more Hifi and impresive..smooth but to my ears Deezer is way more musical and listenable. .bass midrange and treble blah blah blah spoty wins ..but dead boring ...did you do a blind test fufula or were to looking at the numbers while listening ..numbers mean hehaw
post #9 of 9
Thread Starter 

I did blind tests. I also asked other people what they thought and they confirmed what I thought (without me telling them which one *should* sound better or anything like that of course.)

 

320kbps Spotify streams sound better than 128kbps Deezer ones, not that I'm discovering America here (the thing that surprised me was that so much stuff from Deezer was streamed at 128kbps; Rdio streams at 192kbps and they've been getting a lot of flak for that.) Let's say it's an opinion, though, and if some people doubt that -- go ahead and decide for yourselves...


Edited by fufula - 1/3/14 at 6:37am
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Computer Audio

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Computer Audio › Deezer vs Spotify - bitrate / sound quality