Hello everyone,
I want to upgrade from my onboard audio to discrete card + DAC (I use win10)
I play games so I want good positional audio, and from tests, it seems CMMS-3D and SBX are the best (to my taste at least).
I was therefore thinking to take a Sound Blaster Z --> Optical SPDIF --> DAC/AMP, and use SBX for positional audio.
My understanding is that I don't care about the ZxR as the upgraded DAC would be bypassed anyway since I output the sound via SPDIF.
Is my logic correct ?
Other question : is there any benefit in taking the SB Z vs using any card + the SBX Pro software ? Is it easier to setup SBX, or does it offer extra parameters in presence of the card ?
Yes your logic is correct; if you're just after digital out and don't care about the headphone amp, analog inputs/outputs, mic preamp, etc the Z will be equivalent as a digital source. Recon3D as well (they're all SoundCore 3D; the Recon3D has THX in lieu of SBX - I've never done any aggressive side-by-side comparisons (and currently my PC with Recon3D is not hooked up), but they don't sound as far as apart as say, CMSS-Headphone and SBX, or Dolby Headphone and SBX; they seem similar).
I don't know about the SBX downloadable software vs the Z - if I remember right the downloadable software is limited by the capabilities of the device you use it on, so if that device isn't as full featured as the Z that might be a problem, and beyond that I have no idea as far as CPU usage, quality, performance, etc. Certainly the "big selling point" for the Sound Blaster cards is the hardware, so it may be quite similar if you already have a nice set of hardware and its drivers play nice with the SBX downloadable software.
Would I be right in saying that the Z would be a bad choice with 32 Ohm and 18 Ohm IEMs?
Never tried it with IEMs, but both my Recon3D and ZxR do fine enough with my 12 ohm MDR-F1 and 25 ohm TH-900. You may get hiss if the IEMs are *super* sensitive, but I've never heard hiss (from either card) on any of my full-size cans (even ESW9). On the 12 ohm cans I find I'm putting the volume control to a significantly higher position, but there isn't audible distortion or clipping - I think its just a lack of significant gain into lower impedance. Again I'd expect the IEMs to be somewhat more sensitive than the F1 or TH-900, so you probably won't even notice needing to put the volume control higher (also that "put the control higher" is relative to my other cans, so if you're *just* using your single pair of IEMs, there's no comparison, so whatever it is, it is, and life is happy).
Due to the output impedance of the Z being 22 Ohm officially but measured as being even higher than that by some users. For a 32 Ohm IEM you would want a max output impedance of 4 Ohm.
Says what? The whole "rule of 4" or "rule of 8" or whatever that nonsense is is total marketing dribble. That said, a lot of IEMs have pretty reactive impedance response, so you'll see some FR shift as you move from amplifier to amplifier ("but low impedance minimizes that" - no, its just one possible variation; whos to say what is "right" and what is "wrong" unless the manufacturer provides a specification, which few do, and even then, unless you're putting the equipment into a dangerous place (which you aren't) its a preference discussion: does it sound good to you? if yes, then it is what it is, and life is happy).
How much better the ZXR is compared to Asus Xonar D2X ?
% better for music, gaming and movies/tv series ?
thanks
FWIW:
I don't have the D2X, but I have a Razer card that is based on the same C-Media chipset and offers a lot of the same Dolby/DTS packages (however unlike the Asus, offers Razer's "ESP Surround" package as well) - honestly I'd rank it as comparable to the ZxR all things considered - both are good (and if you're just after a straight stereo/5.1 output, they're basically an even match, along with a whole slew of other nice soundcards). The ZxR has a dedicated headphone amplifier built-in, which my Razer lacks, but I know some of the Asus cards also have headphone amplifiers (and if I recall correctly, some of them even use the same TI chip the ZxR has; it sounds good on the ZxR imo). The biggest difference in gaming will be SBX vs Dolby Headphone - random comparo I found on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6ROujJ8Ae8
Honestly I think both SBX and DH do their job, but they do sound different. If you have an overwhelming preference for one or the other, buy whichever satisfies that, but otherwise I'd say the high-end C-Media platform is just as good, excepting any hardware differences (e.g. ZxR has dedicated headphone amp, includes the beam forming mic, etc).