the problem i find with LODs of the style of the L3 and L1 is that, when it's actually in your pocket with your ipod and you're moving around a lot, tension tends to get pressed on the cord (since it sticks out from the rest of the gear), and this leads to issues. I went through about 3 or 4 L1s, each of them malfunctioned within a week due to this problem (granted, it was at my job, which involved constant physical movement, bending, lifting, etc, for 6~8 hours a day). After that I ended up getting a custom LOD that was like the L9 (which didn't exist back then). When the L3 came out I bought one because I wanted to use it in the car (L10 wasn't out yet), and I was curious to see if the thicker cable would alleviate the problem that the L1 had. Well, I used the L3 at work for the first time today, and what I found was that it was not uncommon for the LOD to become partially unplugged from the iPod, regardless of the fact that it has the little buttons on it. Just a few minutes ago I ordered an L9.
So, basically, if you intend to use this setup on the go and be active with it, I believe that the L9 would be a more durable design because the cable does not "stick out" from the rest of the bundle and thus is less likely to be jostled or damaged in your pocket.