I felt less immersed using the DS on Tomb Raider. Suddenly, those thundering gunshots being fired at me had lost all punch and weight, then there was the intricate sound of water that had now become faint and shallow. Yet I could just as easily tell the direction with the DS turned off. I'm personally going down the route now of thinking that there is no substitute for having 5 physical speakers placed around you and stereo is simply the way forward for headphones. I need to try some different games I think but certainly on that one I wasn't feeling it. Will spend a good few hours with it on tonight and see if I can learn to appreciate it more.
I thought the Mixamp contained a DAC anyway? I'm going to look into this Headzone thing and see if I can tell the difference ifI order it.
This Head Zone seems very old and hard to find. Direct is like £700, not sure I'm willing to part with that tbh.
I think you are out of your mind or something is wrong in your set up or your mix amp isn't working right.
I play a ton of games. I have 250 hours into I bf4 alone (ps4-optical out straight to mix amp- then my cans)
I used the a40s for 200 hours of that 250. I have the dial just over half way. The directions of the sound were spot on. The guns shots and explosions sharp as could be. Then I got my m100s. OMG. I had no idea games could sound this good. I can't even begin to listen to to bf4 at the same volume with my m100s the explosions and gunshots are so loud and so sharp they physically hurt my ears.
I just ordered my x1s yesterday and have not gotten them yet, but half the reason I got them is because so many people say how great they are for gaming and a couple wrote how surprised they paired with astro mix amp.
I
Maybe Tomb raiders sound isn't good. More than possible. I beat that game a while ago and don't really remember either way. When I got into good audio, and started to pay attention to game audio, you relieaze some games just sound like ****. Cod games are some of the worst sounding games in the market. Explosions lack bass and gunshot are flat and not sharp at all. (But cod did have good directional mixing)
I think it funny you think 5 separate speakers is better.
When most kids where excited about getting drivers licenses I was saving up and built a a very expensive Klispch surround system. It was like 4,000$ after I finally got the full set and amp/receiver. Once I bought my astro amp and a40s for what 300$ I couldn't believe how much better it was in terms of its surround sound ability. I was so impressed that I thought a40s were AMAZING. It took me years to realize that the a40s are great compared to tv speakers, but hardly "great"
After upgrading to m100s. Being even more impressed I will NEVER drop the cash needed for a full 5.1 or 7.1 speaker system (which btw is 40 year old technology used in theaters as early as the 70's).
If I have 4k to ever drop on a 5.1 speaker system I am going to put it toward more cans, motorcycle, or next car.
(Ands I know you you don't need 4k. Plenty of people like Logitech do make amazing 5.1 and 7.1 systems for 500 to 1000)
Also I live in an apt with paper thin walls so if I want to listen to anything remotely loud speakers are out of the question. However I can turn my m100s up to physical pain level and my wife and neighbors can't hear it.
Edit: I don't mean to come off negative or hostile. I'm just surprised you don't like the mix amp. Say what you want about Astros headphones, but the Mixamp usually gets glowing reviews.