Quote:

Originally Posted by z999 

I've narrowed my search to either the Klipsch S4i or the Maximo iP-595, both offer decent response all over the spectrum, but which of them will be more fitting to rock&metal? I'm looking for precision and balance but still fun earphones. I want the bass to not be overpowering but still have a nice interesting sound.

Definitely the Maximos.

Quote:

Originally Posted by z999 

Because of the better definition? Are the klipsches that bad?
Should I also get some comply replacement tips? Or Shure olives? Will the olives fit?

After such a definite answer I think I'll get the maximos.

The S4 is not a bad earphone but 'precise' and 'balanced' are not words I'd use to describe them. Comply tips (*200 size) fit but aren't really necessary unless you already know that you don't like silicones. Sony Hybrids will fit too. Olives fill not fit.

sound-wise, iP-595 is much better than s4i.

soundwise... care to elaborate?

I have used the 4s and im490 and like the im490 MUCH better. I have heard the 595 is even better. I have put the black comply tips on mine and I lke them a lot. It tones down the bass a bit and gives it more clarity (imho).

I initially had some problems but Andrew at Maximo quickly sent out a replacement - they sound and work great.

If these or any other headphones are causing your iPhone to act erratically, there may be dust or dirt in the earphone jack - Andrew told me about this and after blasting the jack out with compressed air it all works fine.

10/10 go get yourself a pair!