My current favourite combination*: opamp AD 8616, buffers LMH 6643. As soon as I turned it on and started the first song, I had another one of those rare "wow" moments. The upper highs and lows are tamed a bit, the midrange and vocals are beautifully sweet and clear. Almost no distortion when I turned the amp to max, and very little pop/fuzz when I turn it on and off. I would describe the overall sound as rich and mellow.
For a harder hitting sound, I like: opamp dual AD743, buffer AD 8656. Very punchy, with emphasized lows and highs. Seems to suck up battery power though.
*with headphones Shure SRH840, which admitted could use the boost to the midrange
Editing my notes all into one post so it's easier for me to reference...
Buffer notes while using 2:1 opamp AD743:
general impression of 743 as opamp: bright, pronounced high end, very nice mids especially female vocals, a bit hissy
I find the AD8616 to be smoother sounding especially at lower volumes, though with a tiny bit of hiss and it feels like they lose control when I turn it up. Nice mids, though the highs threaten to overwhelm at times. Bass is well defined but a little on the thin side. Awesome space and separation. Battery life ~14 hours. Moderate pop at power up.
The AD8656 handles the big volumes better, but is a bit more brutish sounding. Very punchy with strong bass and highs. Battery life ~14 hours. Big pop at power up, fuzz at down.
With the dummies, sound utterly falls apart at high volumes. Midrange especially gets all flubby and sounds like it's clipping. Low volumes is fine. Sharper more pronounced highs (not sure if I like that yet), but staging sounds a bit shallower than the 8616 or 8656. Battery life ~20 hours. Almost no pops during power up or down.
LMH6643 is indeed more mellow as Hiflight mentioned. Stark contrast to the dummies, and I find myself immediately liking these very much. High volumes hold together very well, but not as well as the 8656. Very slight pop and hiss during power up/down.
Buffers w/opamp AD 8616
general impression of 8616 as opamp - great for midrange: vocals, acoustics, jazz, etc; not as good for bass heavy genres, overall sound signature seems more dependent on buffers compared to other opamps
LMH6643:
super smooth, tamed upper highs and lows, beautiful midrange, very good separation, no distortion at high volumes. Formerly my favourite combo before I got the EL 8201 buffers
AD8532:
very similar to the LMH6643 sound, not quite as smooth but has a bit more power, lose a bit of separation, a tiny bit scratchy at mid volumes and up, perfectly fine at low-mid volumes, really interesting "waterfall" sound when the opamp discharges during powerdown
dummies:
lighter/airier feel compared to LMH6643, separation is lower, lose a bit of the mid richness, gains high end sparkle, loses a bit of control at high volumes (but not nearly as bad as the AD743/dummies combo), very long battery life
AD8656:
restores some of the bass and highs that the AD8616 lacks, very up front presentation, upper end is clean and sharp (finger snaps, hi hats, string plucks), mild distortion when cranked all the way up (more noticeable in the highs)
EL8201:
nice and laid back, good bass extension to ~30Hz, midrange comes forward, slight dip in the lower highs, highs slightly pronounced (hi hats), seems to be a quieter combination.
Buffers with opamp AD8565
(general impression of AD8656 as opamp - emphasized lows and highs, somewhat narrower stage but very "in your face" sound, loads of power but finicky about how it's handled, slight graininess at higher volumes (but you're near earbleed levels at that point anyways))
AD8616:
pretty similar to the reverse config (opamp AD8616, buffers AD8656), highs are much more pronounced and shimmer nicely, lows seem a bit thinner, still has distortion which starts a tiny bit earlier but is less egregious
LMH6643:
very nice balance of highs and lows, really love the sound... but it can't handle power and sound gets grainy and warbly when you turn it up 60%
dummies:
nice rumble in the bass, rather sharp highs, midrange is ok but nothing outstanding, still distorts at high volumes, and even at medium high volumes vocals sometimes sound a bit off, but instruments and electronic sounds are good
I don't have enough AD8656 chips to use as both opamp and buffers, but from some reading here it sounds like they handle the power quite well and don't distort/hiss.
Buffers with opamp LMH6643
dummies:
airier, slightly veiled and relaxed sound, lower power compared to 8656 or 8616 as opamps, slight "concert hall" feel (reverb) adds to spaciousness, mids (vocals) are very forward, midhighs are crisp but feel a bit dry and start to roll off slightly, low volume imbalance (to the right)
AD8616:
slightly more pronounced "concert hall" effect, more energy, not as relaxed, clarity in mids and highs improved a bit with some added shimmer, no roll off in the highs though still a bit dry, bass feels about the same, not as smooth as the reverse combo of opamp 8616 with 6643 buffers but more detailed overall
Buffers with opamp AD4841-2
AD8616:
whoa bright sound (noticeably moreso than any others so far), emphasized and very detailed highs, mid highs tiny bit grainy, fatiguing to my ears, feel like it would be good for studio work though
Buffers with 2:1 opamp TLE2141
EL8201:
a touch of airiness (and maybe reverb?), more on the upper end
richer texture
but a *tiny* bit of graininess with some headphones
lots of power and holds it together without clipping or distorting
bit of a spike on a sub bass response
bit of a tube like sound
LHM6643:
brighter than with EL8201
encoding graininess sounds really bad
strong highs and lows
doesn't hold the power quite as well as EL8201
AD8656:
complex passages with mixed highs and lows sound kinda weird, veiled
AD8616
nice mids, a bit more forward, but slight graininess at the peaks
Buffers with opamp AD8599
EL8201:
louder than TLE2141, but slightly distorted at max
bright sound
midhighs (female vocal range) have a tiny bit of graininess and sibilance
LHM6643:
still bright
faint background hiss? don't hear this with any other combination
bass start to distort badly at medium-high volumes
Buffers with opamp OPA2227p
generally a more relaxed sound
EL8201:
immediately engaging yet laid back sound
a touch of resonance which gives a great sense of live staging
strong bass extension down to 16Hz
lots of power, very loud
my current favourite
LHM6643:
airier, more expansive staging (music feels like it comes from above)
a barely noticeable hint of sibilance
sub bass seems to roll off a little sooner than EL8201
a little harsher on encoding graininess
AD8616:
mids more forward
very nice on vocal and acoustic
good power
but it doesn't have the right impact for rock
bass extension not as good as EL8201
Buffers with opamp LT1358
LHM6643:
crisp and articulate
bass a bit thin
instrumentals come across better than vocals
EL8201:
a bit more relaxed
fuller bass compared to LMH6643
Buffers with opamp RC4560
this is a cheap opamp, very low voltage requirements making it popular for some cmoys
general sound: good midbass, mids slightly recessed
RC4560:
not compatible, very bad static at anything above very low listening levels
EL8201:
slightly cloudy feeling, nothing special
AD8656:
brings back some of the mids, though still a bit congested, bit of sibilance