I'm back at it: I've been listening to 2xLM4562 for a while and have been very happy with the combination. Still I found the motivation to try to improve on it:
- I got my first desktop amp (a tube amp, the Jade) which I'm in love with. I ordered a few tubes and was impressed on how much they changed the sound signature of the amp. The Jade showed me how much better an amp could be and got me back into a rolling mindset.
- The D10 thread is many times more active than the D2 Viper ever was and there are constant improvements made. With the D2 being more powerful (150mW x 2 vs 100mW) it should be possible to make the Viper sound even better than the D10 (as an amp only).
So after a lot of searching and reading I ordered 2 new pairs of DIP opamps: LT1364 and OPA2111. It has been really fun trying a gazillion combinations but of course it greatly increased the likelihood of a misshap and I ended up frying one LT1364
Compared to the stock opamps or LM6172, the new opamps and LM4562 are considerably better. I tried some random combinations at first but pretty quickly it became clear that there were only 3 contenders: LM4562 and the 2 new opamps.
Both OPA2111 and LT1364 are airier than LM4562 and they have a better soundtage too, both more or less at the same level. Both also offer a deeper (lower) bass.
OPA2111 has the most bass of the lot, a tad lower than LT1364 (but really not by much) but it also has a mid-bass hump. It is also the brightest of all. 2 of them together and the sound becomes really too bright. It doesn't feel balanced even if better at higher volume but at low to medium volume the high end push is off-putting (to me at least).
LT1364 is the most natural of the 3 with a good bass extension, good treble but not bright and an excellent midrange. 2xLT1364 sounds really good. It never feels artificial.
LM4562 is the most different of the lot, it's not as open, doesn't go as low and the midrange doesn't sound as rich when compared to the other 2. Also sometimes it can sound "digital" or "plastic". Still it has some characteristics I prefer: the bass has some good punch (the other 2 barely), the treble is just right (in between the 2 others but somehow the lest aggressive) and it is more detailed (textures of violins or bass are richer for example).
After trying all the combinations the best ones use LM4562 because it combines well with the other 2: it brings them the impact they lack for the bass and gives them that extra bit of detail while keeping their extended range.
Mixing OPA2111 with the others tames it a little bit but not enough to my taste. I find the sound aggressive, it's ok for a while specially with LM4562 (the bass is nice) but quickly tiresome.
In the end my choice went to LM4562 (ground) + LT1364 (main): excellent soundstage, good extension, good detail and good impact, sounds excellent at low volume (important to me, I spend many hours a day listening to music through the Viper). The only drawback is that it is a little bit on the bright side, more so than either 2xLM4562 or 2xLT1364.
Note: curiously the reverse combination (switching them around) doesn't work very well, the bass is overemphasized and feels slightly distorted.
What next? I am not aware of any DIP opamps that woud be either a step up or sideways towards a signature I would enjoy more. As for non-DIP ones there's a few I'm curious about (ex: OPA2211A) but without hope for much improvement over what I've tried so far (if any) so I won't bother. Still there's a last one I really want to try: 2xAD797. I need to find a fellow head-fier to solder them on a brown dog for me though.