The problem with the iPod is that the signal path is "contaminated" by the numerous other electronics (I am no electrical engineer, so excuse my use of vague, non-technical words). Even the path from the DAC to the line-out is "contaminated". Hence, what the Redwine mod does is to go straight from the DAC to the line-out by bypassing the stuff in the middle. This is explained in a rather concise form on their website.
I quote:
The iMod Details
Even if you use the very best iPod cable with your stock iPod, you are still not avoiding the serious degradation
of sound that results from the cumulative effects of the following "offenders" in the signal path:
-- The low quality stock SMT coupling caps after the Wolfson WM8975 DAC (used in all 4th gen. iPods)
-- Opamp output stage following the Wolfson DAC
-- The minuscule circuit board traces that travel from the top of the mother board down to the
dock connector jack
-- SMD resistors and inductors directly in the signal path
-- The dock connector jack at the bottom of the iPod
-- The signal path inside the iPod dock, which contains: the dock connector plug, a very cheap
ribbon cable, more minuscule pcb traces, SMD resistors, and finally the line out jack.
The goal of the Red Wine iMod is to significantly minimize the analog signal path that follows the
output of the internal Wolfson dac chip. Using D.H. Labs silver wire, we take the analog output
(line out) off of the dac chip and send it directly to the internal 1/8" headphone jack (converting it
into a dedicated line-out jack) via high-end Black Gate Non-Polarized NX HiQ coupling capacitors.
The result of the Red Wine iMod is a superb sounding, battery-powered, miniature-sized digital playback
source with fantastic features and a stellar user interface. Of course, we only take credit for making it sound
so good!
There we go. Yes, you are correct that "the Red Wine mod had more to do with removing things than adding". I hope this has made it clearer.
For more, click
here